willo said:At first I though yuk
Then worked on it a bit.
If we finished 13th it means our 3rd rounder would be pick 49 (would change a bit with academy/fs bids)
If they finished 8th their 2nd rounder would be pick 26. In effect Ups us 13 picks or so.
Daw and pick 26 for Vickery and pick 49. Hmmm...a 440 point upgrade. Enough for Steele I wonder?
mrposhman said:Pretty sure you have your numbers round the wrong way. If North finish 8th then thats Pick 29. If we finish 13th then our 3rd would be 42 (got the 13 pick upgrade right though).
Reckon we'd be better with the compo pick personally, especially if he gets paid enough for an end of 1st round pick. As a minimum we would get a 2nd, which would be around Pick 24.
Really depends on whether we are after a FA. If we are, then our compo pick will be downgraded so thats when we would consider trading rather than allowing free agency to happen. Personally don't reckon teams will want to trade for him, but as a freebie then there will be a few teams after him.
btoz_01 said:Had enough opportunities at our club to be a :star
His good performances are few and far between
Hopefully there were a few clubs interested in him after last night and increases his trade value
CC TIGER said:Like Grif I just worry about there want to get to contest after contest, Jack wants to be the man and more often then not is.......passion boys
CC TIGER said:He was on his own , in the forward pocket ,pre ,3rd qtr the other night , just in front of where I was, ball was in the back pocket an Tyrone was shuffling along, I though geez TV present and he kept shuffling along and in the end he ended up hitting the ball hard and taking the mark and we may have got a goal out of it. Point been he was been too lasy at first to go hard an present, but when he actually found himself in the position where he had too, he did an did well. Like Grif I just worry about there want to get to contest after contest, Jack wants to be the man and more often then not is.......passion boys
willo said:But the idea is still there. Only a couple of spots out. But if we were interested in Daw (someone made mentioned we may be)plus a 13 spot pick upgrade might have some merit. Not that I'm keen on Daw. I think we can do better.
Sounds like he timed his run n attack on the contest perfectly, what's the beef?CC TIGER said:He was on his own , in the forward pocket ,pre ,3rd qtr the other night , just in front of where I was, ball was in the back pocket an Tyrone was shuffling along, I though geez TV present and he kept shuffling along and in the end he ended up hitting the ball hard and taking the mark and we may have got a goal out of it. Point been he was been too lasy at first to go hard an present, but when he actually found himself in the position where he had too, he did an did well. Like Grif I just worry about there want to get to contest after contest, Jack wants to be the man and more often then not is.......passion boys
tigerlove said:Why would North give up Daw AND 13 spots for Vickery. Overall stats this year Daw has been better than Vickery
http://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?playerStatus1=A&tid1=13&playerStatus2=A&tid2=15&type=A&pid1=3390&pid2=3114&fid1=S&fid2=S
I tried to tell myself that TM. A hard working key forward , would have been up on the wing a lot quicker, he just wasn't keen on getting there, it was just the bench screaming out to him to push. I'm not one to bash a player for the sake of it, I just thought this was just a perfect example of Vickery the footballer, talented and can play if he commits, however he just dosent get to go tests anywhere near enough and that's just a pure attitude issue imhoTigerMasochist said:Sounds like he timed his run n attack on the contest perfectly, what's the beef?
Baloo said:Football isn't the be all and end all for him I guess.
Baloo said:Football isn't the be all and end all for him I guess.
TT33 said:This may well be the case, but it is the way he earns a living, so he should commit to it far more than he is atm.
I'm sure that most of us do so in our own work lives. We would soon be job hunting if we didn't.
tigersnake said:He'll probably go as FA I reckon. A couple more games like that and we'll get a second round pick at least.
se7en said:Except for average goals and marks - which are the two major stats for a forward.
Daw has more clangers as well
Only 5 games for the year.
tigerlove said:Yep that 1 mark (not contested, Daw turns the stats on him in that regard) and .7 goals per game should make all the difference. That doesn't make up for all the other areas that Daw has been superior. Seriously North aren't going to give Daw AND 15 drop pick for Vickery. You may as well keep Daw, more upside.