Whats happening at Moorabin Mr Thomas. | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Whats happening at Moorabin Mr Thomas.

Kosi is streets ahead of Riewoldt, however he will never make it as a player due to injuries.

The destroying of Riewoldt is due to Thomas Making him captain when he was not ready.

Thomas is a dud he knifed Blight in the back took his job with the help of his buddy butters. Could you image how many flags Stkilda would have now with Blight as coach???
 
duro said:
Kosi is streets ahead of Riewoldt, however he will never make it as a player due to injuries.

The destroying of Riewoldt is due to Thomas Making him captain when he was not ready.

Thomas is a dud he knifed Blight in the back took his job with the help of his buddy butters. Could you image how many flags Stkilda would have now with Blight as coach???
Good post Duro.Saints would have won a flag by now under Blight.
 
Remember when Thomas went on that wacky cabage juice diet, under the care of his natropath? Of course he has subsequently put back all the weight he lost, but I have this mental picture of him lying on the table with somebody slapping some fish together and chanting above him!

This guy seriously believes in wierd stuff, who would you rather have as a coach, the scientist Neil Craig, or the wacky Thomas. I know who I would prefer.
 
linuscambridge said:
Remember when Thomas went on that wacky cabage juice diet, under the care of his natropath? Of course he has subsequently put back all the weight he lost, but I have this mental picture of him lying on the table with somebody slapping some fish together and chanting above him!

This guy seriously believes in wierd stuff, who would you rather have as a coach, the scientist Neil Craig, or the wacky Thomas. I know who I would prefer.

To answer that Linus, one only has to look at the rate of improvement from the lists available to both coaches last year.......Like comparing cheese and chalk dust!
 
duro said:
Thomas is a dud he knifed Blight in the back took his job with the help of his buddy butters.  Could you image how many flags Stkilda would have now with Blight as coach???

If we had Blight as a coach, neither Aussie Jones or Fraser Gehrig would've played past 2003, and Loewe, Burke and Harvey all would've been delisted at the end of the 2001. AND, our coach would still be missing training regularly because of golf.

C'mon, Blight was a genius in his time, but was past it when he took on our coaching job. He had lost the players by round 5. Before a game in 2001, there was no preparation for the game, and Blight's amazing pre-game speech, was simply "I want you to read everything on this white-board very carefully". He brought out the whiteboard and there was nothing on it. How the hell do you win premierships by doing that?

I think it was Aussie Jones, who, when asked of Blight's gameplan, said "I don't think there actually is a gameplan...just lots of confusion". Now why do you think we would've won two premierships with Blight?

Blight's heart was never in it, golf was a much higher priority for him than St Kilda, and the only reason he took on the job was because of the massive pay-check we offered him.

And to all you people who think GT hated Blight and stole his job, Thomas was actually the one who suggested we go after Blight. And I reckon that's the only major thing GT's done wrong.
 
mad-saint-guy said:
duro said:
Thomas is a dud he knifed Blight in the back took his job with the help of his buddy butters.  Could you image how many flags Stkilda would have now with Blight as coach???

If we had Blight as a coach, neither Aussie Jones or Fraser Gehrig would've played past 2003, and Loewe, Burke and Harvey all would've been delisted at the end of the 2001. AND, our coach would still be missing training regularly because of golf.

C'mon, Blight was a genius in his time, but was past it when he took on our coaching job. He had lost the players by round 5. Before a game in 2001, there was no preparation for the game, and Blight's amazing pre-game speech, was simply "I want you to read everything on this white-board very carefully". He brought out the whiteboard and there was nothing on it. How the hell do you win premierships by doing that?

I think it was Aussie Jones, who, when asked of Blight's gameplan, said "I don't think there actually is a gameplan...just lots of confusion". Now why do you think we would've won two premierships with Blight?

Blight's heart was never in it, golf was a much higher priority for him than St Kilda, and the only reason he took on the job was because of the massive pay-check we offered him.

And to all you people who think GT hated Blight and stole his job, Thomas was actually the one who suggested we go after Blight. And I reckon that's the only major thing GT's done wrong.
Reckon you're right about Blighty, MSG. The big question though is why the hell did they chase him so hard when it was bloody obvious from a hundred miles away that he had well and truly lost interest while coaching the Crows. Of all the possible coaching choices you could have made Blighty was the one that was totally wrong and set the club back a couple of years.
 
You gave Blight about 8 weeks ( Or grant thomas did)
STkilda finished on the bottom for about 2 years taking all the draft picks!
So it is not like Thomas took you up the ladder. Maybe Blight realised this and decided to worry about teaching crap players like aussie!
Blight did the same at Adelaide when he got rid of some seniour players and finished low in his first year!
And this crap about game plans! How did Blight manage to get the cats into 5 Grand finals and Adelaide into 2 winning ones without a game plan!
What a load of crap! Even if he didnt teach this to the players in 8 weeks i am sure he had a plan. Thomas is not worth the scum on Blights feet! Look at the two mens history!!! player and coach!!!!
 
Blight versus Thomas - I know who i'd have more respect for and who i would rather play for no doubts.
 
I still think the Siants are on the right track, there window to win it is the next 2 years.

It takes every side that wins a flag about three years of being in the finals and just learning finals footy.

Look at Sydeny this year, always in the finals and then one year it happens.