When was football at it's best? | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

When was football at it's best?

Footy has always been bloody pumping, it's because of the RFC's lack of success we specify a particular era.

I can bet your bottom dollar if the RFC was consistent across all the decades since the mid sixties, then there would be an appreciation of our club's performance for the last 50 years.
 
geoffryprettyboy said:
Footy has always been bloody pumping, it's because of the RFC's lack of success we specify a particular era.

I can bet your bottom dollar if the RFC was consistent across all the decades since the mid sixties, then there would be an appreciation of our club's performance for the last 50 years.

I got to call you on that GPB. I think we are intelligent to separate the clubs success compared to the style of the game. I just think that football is headed in a dangerous direction and as someone said the things that we all love about football, screamers, hard bumps, great skills, unstoppable forwards kicking 100's and high scores are slowly fading into oblivion or as Mike Tyson once said "fading into Bolivia", Regardless of our own clubs success/lack of it we can still pick out the facets of the game that are disappearing and taking the game some where that we don't like.
 
Definitely between the mid/late 80's through to the mid 90's.

The game has completely gone of the rails as an exciting spectacle since the mid 90's.
 
just ask yourself - what was the best GF you have seen (apart froma Rich win) - for me it was 89
Hawthorn - Geelong - it had it all, the hits, the goals, the comeback, the contest the legends of Brereton & Ablett
 
Easily the seventies for me. 

There were plenty of high marks and running football, someone like Robbie McGhie would win the ball across half-back, kick long and a pack would form.  Then someone would fly across in front to take a huge mark or a strong fist would come over the top and punch the ball clear to waiting runners, keen to feed off the contest.  Players like Gary Dempsey or Peter Knights would sometimes take three or four match-saving marks deep in defence in the last quarter.  When the mighty full-forwards led to the ball the crowd would rise in expectation.  All exhilarating stuff!

It was a time when coaches thrived on the contest.  Their game plans were all about having players who could win the contested ball all over he ground. 

The last ten years or so has been all about avoiding the contest.  It is more efficient but there is not so much to like about it.
 
have heard from an old friend, Tom Hanna years ago that the depression years were his favourite years of footy.

At the time i thought nothing of it "just another ole guy living off the memories' type thing, but when you think of it, so many of the greatest players to play sprung from that period in the game.

Pratt, Bunton, Skilton, Coventry, Collier, Valence and not to mention our own Jack Titus, the original 'terminator' Basil McCormack, Percy Bently, Gordon Strang and one other bloke, whats his name?  ;D

He said the game at the time was very skillfull and fast. As a spectator on the wing it was like watching a game of tennis. Now remember, Pratt kicked 150 in '33 and that record still stands today.

No quarter was ever given between players, sharpened studs were prevelent too  :help which later lead to pregame stud inspections :o .

He undoubtably said that Laurie Nash was THE most skillful footy player to lace a boot. I retorted "Better than Ablett" he poked me in the chest and said "NO COMPARISION SON!"  :clap

Gotta love listening to the old guys talk footy. Recently on Grumpy Old Men, I cant remember who said it was but an old legend was asked something like "gee you wouldnt last long out there on the field today would you?" to which a reply something like " thats very true but i tell ya what... these punces now wouldnt last one minute on the field back in my day!"  :clap :clap :clap

I too thought the 70's were the best until that day. God something like 75-80 thousand rocked up to GF's and finals  :clap and unlike todays, live in Toorak but follow Tiges sect, games back then would of been very territorial and added to the sense of battle on gameday.

As generation after generation passes this earth, each thinking they're gods gift till history proves otherwise, its great to listen to previous generations and share their experiences.
 
80,s and 90,s for mine...been a few enjoyable glimpses at times in recent years...like the liars at theior best....history is gonna repeat itself......because Im comin home ;D
 
I reckon footy was great throughout all my years of following it up until I started to notice the beginning of a move to risk-averse, basketball-like, super-drilled, possession-style footy about 96-98. Now its undisputable. The game is up-one-end until the team hits the flood at the HF line, then down the other for more of the same. Footy was much better when it was the old ‘back your team mate down field to beat his man’ risky, have a go footy.

Another thing, I liked watching footy better standing up in a random crowd. I really hate this namby-pamby obsession with bloody reserved seats and focaccias and dunnies you can eat your tea off. I liked the grotty old MCG Southern stand urinals and standing room. I liked going to Vic park and the Western Oval standing next to toothless drunk opposition ( and tiger) barrackers. I enjoyed myself. I still enjoy myself, but its lost that crazy edge.
 
craig said:
The 70s and  80s for sure and early 90s with heaps more contests, big grabs, superstar fullforwards, ongoing battles between star backs ie Doull, Knights, Roos, Dench, Carter, Langford, Andrews and the forwards such as Roach, Carmen, Taylor, Dunstall, Lockett, Ablett iconic louts and characters and most pertinant the old suburban grounds ie Windy Hill, Western Oval, Princess Park, Vic Park even tho some of these grounds were abominable fortressess they promoted tribalism which was great standing in the outer with a pie and a can of VB ahhhahhhh the good ol days.

Agree with every word.

Today's game would have no place for a Leigh Matthews - possibly the greatest player ever - and to me at least, an indictment on the direction the game is moving.
 
tigersnake said:
Another thing, I liked watching footy better standing up in a random crowd.  I really hate this namby-pamby obsession with bloody reserved seats and focaccias and dunnies you can eat your tea off.  I liked the grotty old MCG Southern stand urinals and standing room.  I liked going to Vic park and the Western Oval standing next to toothless drunk opposition ( and tiger) barrackers.  I enjoyed myself.  I still enjoy myself, but its lost that crazy edge.

:rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl :rofl
 
blx, think you'll find Skilton played in the 60s.

Can't wait for history to repeat itself in the shape of a competitive, successful side like the Tigers of old.
 
I'm an old codger that thinks it gets no better than Richos 10 against the doggies in 2004. Right up there with Balmy taking on the entire Carlton backline and Fowler putting Big Nick down for the count.  And Royce coming on as 19th man in the 3rd quarter to beat the crap out of the pies (again). 

The best GF - 73 Rich flogging the Carlsum.
Best non RFC grand final - 1970 when Barrasi changed football forever.
 
tigersnake said:
I reckon footy was great throughout all my years of following it up until I started to notice the beginning of a move to risk-averse, basketball-like, super-drilled, possession-style footy about 96-98.  Now its undisputable.  The game is up-one-end until the team hits the flood at the HF line, then down the other for more of the same.  Footy was much better when it was the old ‘back your team mate down field to beat his man’ risky, have a go footy.

Another thing, I liked watching footy better standing up in a random crowd.  I really hate this namby-pamby obsession with bloody reserved seats and focaccias and dunnies you can eat your tea off.  I liked the grotty old MCG Southern stand urinals and standing room.  I liked going to Vic park and the Western Oval standing next to toothless drunk opposition ( and tiger) barrackers.  I enjoyed myself.  I still enjoy myself, but its lost that crazy edge.
Ah nice one Tigersnake ,a man after my own heart.
 
Footy was best when we didnt suck !!!

Unfortunately i was too young to savour such fervour, excitement and be able to be arrogant to other supporters. :(