Which Geelong players wouldn't get a game at your club.

[the claw]

okay an interesting thread over on big footy.started by a geelong tosser bignoting his team but interesting never the less. seeing as how we are supposed to be modelling ourselves on geelong i thought it would be a good question to ask here.
personally theres some geelong players i would not pick due to age but we are talking the here and now.

geelongs best 30 odd loosly in position

harley scarlett hunt
enright taylor mackie
ling bartel selwood
johnson mooney miburn
chapman hawkins varcoe
ottens corey ablett

int from blake lonergan rooke stokes wojcinski kelly byrnes gamble

for me some who may not get a game at richmond.
mackie soft as butter. taylor who has been harshly judged after just one afl season has a bit to offer down the track imo.mooney have never rated him in fact hes a dud should not really include him in this list though hes in front of most kpfs at our club..hawkins not at the moment maybe down the track.
lonergan just dont see it with him stokes wojcinski byrnes kelly are some others who may not get a go in the 22.

finally not really what the question is about but a combined best 22 would probably go something like this.

B thursfield scarlett hunt
HB enright harley moore
C deledio selwood corey
HF johnson riewoldt ablett
F chapman richo brown
R ottens bartel cousins
Int from. simmonds milburn cotchin foley tuck ling newman

anyway lets see shall we.

 

[hutstar]

Sounds about right to me. Almost, dare i say it, generous.

 

[Jason King]

Replace Milburn with Woja.

 

[Tigers of Old]

Looks about right clawsy, be interesting to do a Hawthorn one.

 

[Streak]

I'd say it is about right too.

The only thing I'd look at is Hunt. Don't rate him that highly. Would probably play Moore in his spot, and replace Mackie with either Woj, Kelly or maybe Bowden.

 

[Pezza]

Rooke would have to be in most teams first 18, wouldn't he???

I like Kelly and hypothetically (if he overcomes his injury) Egan would be no. 1 key defender, maybe :-\

 

[Sly]

Mooney & Stokes. Stokes wouldn't get a game in my back yard if it were up to me. (And, since it's my back yard, it is up to me ), and Mooney was shown up for the complete dud he is in that interstate game - did he get a stat?

 

[mb64]

Mooney & Stokes. Stokes wouldn't get a game in my back yard if it were up to me. (And, since it's my back yard, it is up to me ), and Mooney was shown up for the complete dud he is in that interstate game - did he get a stat?

I'd play both in our side

 

[Ruthless Tigers ?]

WHich Geelong player wouldnt get a game at our club....or rather shouldnt....DONUT!

 

[nwonash]

How can you pick Ottens? He is always injured. Or is it he lacks heart?

 

[Chocco]

Surely Mooney, Mackie and Wojak would get a game in our team. Looks like a pretty awesome team, it shows that our players are on the way.

 

[shamekha]

Hawkins is a big lump... Will go the way of that carlscum captain he reminds me of... And i have never liked Stokes, just looks good in a good team. if he had to work for it he wouldn't, reminds me of that weasal Milne. They wouldn't make it in my Tiger team.

Also agree Mooney showed he struggles under high pressure..

 

[the claw]

Looks about right clawsy, be interesting to do a Hawthorn one.

hmm just quickly would go something like this

backs brown/sewell scarlett harley/gilham/
h/backs enright/milburn croad hodge
centre bateman bartel selwood
h/f johnson roughead rioli/stokes
forwards chapman/osborne franklin williams/mooney
rucks ottens mitchell ablett
int campbell corey ling ellis