Yellows v Blacks (oh, all right, Whites) | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Yellows v Blacks (oh, all right, Whites)

tiger in the night

Rex's mother at work.
Mar 4, 2004
1,045
0
Yellow Team v White Team time coming soon. Always the best pre-season game of the year.

Who do you like as match-ups? How would you select the teams?

For me I would like a more even contest this year than last year – no Richo v Archibald match-ups (the poor kid was severely embarrassed for a half) – a contest between equals.

Some of the juicy individual match-ups for mine would be:

Richo v Hall: now let’s see how much you’ve improved Mr Hall
Newman v Johnno: the newbie against the incumbent
Deledio v Tambling: mouth watering contest
Pettifer v Hartigan: skills and niceness v courage and nasty: a Dyer’ere ding-dong special
Pattison v J Bowden: can Patto utilise his height advantage? Has he got smarts?
Cogs v Foley: who will win the tackle count? the handball count?
Polo v Tuck: just love the look of this match-up

So, to the teams – assuming Brown will not play and Chaffey is still recovering from OP:

WFB: Humm J.Bowden Thursfield
YFF: Krakouer Pattison P.Bowden

WHB: Hartigan Schulz Jackson
YHF: Pettifer Simmonds Moore

WC: Newman Tuck Casserley
YC: Johnson Polo O-Nicholls

WHF: Meyer Richardson Tivendale
YHB: Raines Hall Roach

WFF: Rodan Hughes Limbach
YFB: Hyde McGuane Kellaway

WR: Knobel Coughlan Tambling
YR: Stafford Foley Deledio

WINT: Graham Howat
YINT: Gaspar White

Result: I reckon the whites will belt’em. Too much pride from Joel, Newman, Tuck and Coughlan, too much nasty from Hartigan, Jackson and Knobel and too much talent from Schulz, Richo, Meyer and Tambling.

Or the game will be abandoned after an all-in brawl that will emanate from an encounter between siblings Pat and Joel Bowden.

GO TIGES.
 
Interesting idea which i think is great.

Only difference is that I'd test them in the positions where Terry might play them in 2006.

Hall (CHF) v Schulz (CHB)
P.Bowden (CHF) v J.Bowden (CHB)

Simmonds v Knobel (Rucks)

Tuck v Coughlan (Centres)

Limbach (FF) v Thursfield (FB)
Hughes (FF) v McGuane (FB)

Foley v Rodan (Rover)

A host of these sub-battles going on.

Great idea, Titn.
 
Hartigan (BP) v Krakouer (FP)
Casserley (BP) v Meyer (FP)

Newman (HBF) v Pettifer (HFF)
Oakley-Nicholls (HBF) v Tambling (HFF)

Roach v Raines (Wingers)
Tivendale v Deledio (Wingers)
 
Phantom said:
Hartigan (BP) v Krakouer (FP)
Casserley (BP) v Meyer (FP)

Newman (HBF) v Pettifer (HFF)
Oakley-Nicholls (HBF) v Tambling (HFF)

Roach v Raines (Wingers)
Tivendale v Deledio (Wingers)
Geez, we really are trying to destroy Tivendale's confidence once & for all. :hihi
 
Here we go:

Hartigan             Thursfield                Jackson
Krakouer            Limbach                   Moore

Newman              Schulz                     Humm
Pettifer                 Hall                         White

Roach                   Tuck                        Tivendale
Raines                  Coughlan                Deledio

Tambling               P.Bowden               Chaffey
Oakley-Nicholls      J.Bowden               Hyde

Pattison                  Hughes                 Meyer
Graham                   McGuane               Casserley

Simmonds              Polo                         Foley
Knobel                   Howat                      Rodan

Interchange from Stafford, Richo, Gaspar, Johnson, Kellaway, Brown ......

Hope I haven't left anyone out.  :-\
 
Phantom said:
Here we go:

Hartigan             Thursfield                Jackson
Krakouer            Limbach                   Moore

Newman              Schulz                     Humm
Pettifer                 Hall                         White

Roach                   Tuck                        Tivendale
Raines                  Coughlan                Deledio

Tambling               P.Bowden               Chaffey
Oakley-Nicholls      J.Bowden               Hyde

Pattison                  Hughes                 Meyer
Graham                   McGuane               Casserley

Simmonds              Polo                         Foley
Knobel                   Howat                      Rodan

Interchange from Stafford, Richo, Gaspar, Johnson, Kellaway, Brown ......

Hope I haven't left anyone out.  :-\

Looking at that on paper there is so many great matchups that the score really becomes irrelevant. As long as you beat your man you have done your job for the day.