The issue is really simple. Is Shane a part of the future? No.
Weird post tbh - we all know he is not part of our long term future - so - we are not talking about 2023 or 2024, we talking about squeezing finals games in 2022 and how best to retire a champion respectfully.
Is Fyfe part of Freo‘s future, doubt it, but they play him, same with any player in their last year at any club.