-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Rating the Superhunks
- Thread starter Dyer'ere
- Start date
Do you really want me to go thru the list of nominees? There are even more duds on that list.
Matty Clarke departs.
Currently
Gibcus looks set to make it so long as stays injury free.
Still a fair degree of uncertainty with all the others.
Currently
Gibcus looks set to make it so long as stays injury free.
Still a fair degree of uncertainty with all the others.
Gibcus & Clarke ACLs..
Sonsie & Banks struggling to establish their positions in the snrs...
Brown & MJ leading this poll atm...
Meanwhile Matt Clarke has taken another job..
Sonsie & Banks struggling to establish their positions in the snrs...
Brown & MJ leading this poll atm...
Meanwhile Matt Clarke has taken another job..
Matt might prove to be a good list manager but I think there is enough evidence now that he is not a good judge of junior talent. Just too many of his picks haven't come on.
Hi hit
His hit rate in drafting young talent is pretty good. Not one recruiting manager gets them all and don’t forget we have had very few high picks in recent years.
Who do you think will turn into A graders outside of Gibcus in his picks since 2018 ?
A few weeks ago many had Brown written off.
I have a small degree of confidence that at some stage this year everyone will be trying to squeeze into the Banks vault like they are jumping on the Brown train.
Brown has shown AFL traits from his first game. Tracking beautifully. Superhunk!
yeah, small, maybe medium. i still think Banks will have a successful AFL career, i am just not quite willing to say with 100% certainty. yet.Small degree of confidence?
The worst bit, Adeladie were convinced we would take Solgio with one of our picks. We were definitely interested.
We rated Banks ahead of Solgio in our ratings. After talking Brown, we decided we needed another outside type and ignored the mid. We watched Sonsie enough to draft him, we had a clear line of sight on Solgio. They are best mates. It's another case of Richmond ignoring pure mids. It goes on and on.
And don't say "DiD YoU RaTe HiM? If NoT ShUT uP!" I'm a rank amateur with a keyboard, I'm not watching games as my job.
We rated Banks ahead of Solgio in our ratings. After talking Brown, we decided we needed another outside type and ignored the mid. We watched Sonsie enough to draft him, we had a clear line of sight on Solgio. They are best mates. It's another case of Richmond ignoring pure mids. It goes on and on.
And don't say "DiD YoU RaTe HiM? If NoT ShUT uP!" I'm a rank amateur with a keyboard, I'm not watching games as my job.
Last edited:
Speaking of cursed, its looking like Freo are gonna finish top 6 or so when everyone expected them to be around the bottom 4. Great.
If you think about it, we've been badly cursed and ripped off in so many respects since 2021. It's been a bad 4 years.
It’s weird that it’s been like this for so long. If nothing else, it’s generally easier to get a midfielder to successfully play another position than it is to get a back or half forward to successfully move into the midfield.
