Club Best and Fairest for 2003

[tiga]

I didn't put Wayne Campbell in the list due to injury but IMO he was going to be right in it until his season was ended prematurely. So have a vote and we'll see how accurate the result is at the end of the season.

Sorry for the Typo on Johnson. I'll never forgive myself! ;D

 

[MC24]

Sorry for the Typo on Johnson. I'll never forgive myself! ;D

I'll forgive you tiga.

Don't know if I'll forgive you for the typo on Mark Coughlan though.

 

[shawry]

I went for Chaffey as Mr.Consistency but Cogs and AK are good chances aswell.

 

[Richos_girl_]

I'd love to see Richo win his first but I'm putting my money on Andy Kellaway. Is he the most underrated player in the league or what.

 

[shawry]

I'd love to see Richo win his first but I'm putting my money on Andy Kellaway. Is he the most underrated player in the league or what.

Him and Mark Chaffey.

 

[kb7882]

1. Chaffey
2. Daylight
3. AK
4. Toss a coin, Cogs or Staff. (had a very good first half)

 

[tiga]

Sorry for the Typo on Johnson. I'll never forgive myself! ;D

I'll forgive you tiga.

Don't know if I'll forgive you for the typo on Mark Coughlan though.

Sorry MC I just noticed that one too! Just goes to show that eating lunch and typing at the same time can have a disasterous effect! ;D

 

[Dean3]

If last season's B & F is anything to go by, Coughlan is a certainty to win it this year. Chaff and AK would be the dangers.

 

[tiga]

Based on consistency you would have to go for Chaffey.
Coughlan has had a couple of quiet ones whereas Chaffey IMO has been in our best 3 for every game so far this year. Go the Chaffster !

 

[mightytiges]

I would say Cogs with Chaffey, AK and Tivs next in line.

How do they determine the votes for the B/F? I think someone here mentioned before it's not a 3-2-1 system.

 

[Dean3]

No it's some complex thing mt, something like giving each player a rating out of 10 or similar.

 

[mightytiges]

No it's some complex thing mt, something like giving each player a rating out of 10 or similar.

Cheers Dean.

 

[Joel Bowden fan]

I think Cougs will win no competition his been the star of this year and will definately get more best and grounds then any other player

 

[cogs_is_sexy24]

cogs might get it, because even though he has had a few quiet games (plus he didnt play vs. west coast), he has had an outstanding season, and there have been a lot of games where he has been ranked no. 1 for us. if you read the herald sun, after every game they have the stats on every player, and you would notice that cogs has the best average for the season in richmond.

but then again, chaff..........

 

[zacs56]

I would say Cogs with Chaffey, AK and Tivs next in line.

How do they determine the votes for the B/F? I think someone here mentioned before it's not a 3-2-1 system.

Good call but staf should be on level ground with Tivs. Why don't you make something hard by trying to pick Coburgs best three. :'( :'( :'(

 

[Rosy]

How do they determine the votes for the B/F? I think someone here mentioned before it's not a 3-2-1 system.

On a Monday the 4 coaches each give 5 players votes out of 10.

 

[JohnF]

I voted for Chaffey, as I think he deserves it, but if I was betting on it, I'd go for Coughlan. I hope the top 5 players are A. Kellaway, Cogs, Stafford, Tivendale and Chaffey (in no particular order).

I hope Richo and Bowden don't get anywhere near the top ten, but I wouldnt be surprised if they are right up there.

 

[g0tigers]

I went for cogs, but i wouldnt mind seeing chaff get it.

 

[tiga]

Make sure you get you vote in today if you haven't already done so as I will be finalising it tonight, Although it looks like Cogs will be a clear winner with the ever reliable Chaff coming in second.