Geez, I hope you meant Zak Guthrie there eZyT. Cam's managed a couple of hundred games n BnF at the Moggies, not quite VFL standard. His little bro Zak on the other hand, dud delist..
Josh Scache, Jake Aarts, Cam Guthrie, Rhys Matheson, are your prototype VFL blokes by which the index is measured. Seriously flawed Blokes who arent gonna get any better.
I can see that he has deficiencies mrposhman, but "won't win a premiership with him in the best 22" is demonstrably incorrect, unless you think that leaving Marlion out of the 2019 premiership team and replacing him with Ross (as was the clubs initial plan) would mean we're still stuck on 12 premierships.I wouldn't move him on, but we won't win a premiership with him in the best 22 IMO. He's a back up player in the AFL in my view. I'd love to see Banks take that wing by the end of the year. I have high hopes for him.
Ditto.Happy with his exclusion. They've had a good look.
Hopefully in the VFL he gets run down a lot. To the point he adapts. And grows.Ross was definitely more blue collar in the 2s on the weekend. First hands on the ball stuff. Would have led all-comers I'd say. It was the kind of game his fans say he should be given the chance to play at the top level. But he's not dynamic, that's my problem. Grinder. And he got run down because he persists with this delusion that he has time. Still, a good showing.