For sure, I agree with that influencing factor. But in saying that I note that my mother in law is from staunch Irish Catholic roots. Not the same antipathy among her clan. Wouldn't say they love them or hate them - apathetic really. But you'd have different quirks within each region of Australia depending on their generational experiences. Victoria for example had far more conflict between the Irish Catholics and the blue blood establishment than most other parts of Australia throughout it's history, which would fuel antipathy.
But in Tasmania, it was said when she was growing up, that the north of Tasmania was run by Protestants and the south by Catholics. And the settlement patterns probably explain this. Southern Tasmania far higher convict concentration than the north, that was more weighted to free settler farmers. You can see it in voting patterns too. The north is the centre of the landed gentry Liberal Party, the south is very ALP and GRN voting. In the south, the state public service was for many years a Catholic (largely Irish Catholic) closed shop. So I suppose they have long since buried their antipathy by carving out a sphere of influence in their pocket of Australia over many generations, that they don't really care either way about the royals.
My family background was mainly English convicts (although crossed with Scots and Irish married in, plus a bit of Bavarian). Non-conformist Protestant rural poor and working class. Locked out of the Catholic closed shops while at the same time, felt no affiliation with the blue blood Protestants they felt disdain from. I suppose we have a chip on our shoulder and view all groups with suspicion
. My grandmother seemed to always say the word 'Catholic' like she had a bad smell under her nose. Not absolute contempt. But you knew they were the 'other' tribe. And my uncle, when he was accepted for a partial scholarship to a prestigious Anglican private school, turned that down, as he felt those people weren't really his tribe either. Generational class and cultural hang ups and their origins make for fascinating history.
Last edited:
