Playing List Review by MILLER | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

Playing List Review by MILLER

gustiger12

Its Tiger Time
Jan 22, 2003
9,933
2
www.thaigerpics.com
The Age Realfooty 10.07.2003

'Selfish' Tigers may face axe
By Jake Niall
July 10 2003


Richmond has foreshadowed some tough decisions about its playing list at season's end following a frank internal assessment of the club's football operations.

Richmond football director Greg Miller has delivered a mid-season report to the club board and made recommendations on how the club can be transformed from its present struggling state to become a consistent top-four contender - and his plan includes a tight player-payments regime.

Richmond president Clinton Casey said Miller's review - which he described as "the big one" for 2003 - was "an honest appraisal" of the playing list which pinpointed the key weaknesses and suggestions on how the club could be improved.

Miller, while reluctant to divulge details of the review, yesterday made it clear that Richmond would not achieve lasting success unless its players were prepared to sacrifice some money in the coming years.


Casey said Miller had also recommended some recruiting strategies and indicated that there would be tough decisions at season's end on players.

"This assessment of our list is as honest as it's ever been," he said.

Casey said the board was aware that the list lacked depth. "We know we've got no depth," he said. The board, he said, had been impressed with Miller's review and was optimistic it now had the right structures to achieve future success.

"We're impressed with this honest appraisal of our list and the structure, of our shortcomings and the sort of players we want to become a perpetual top-four contender."

Miller said the club's first priority had to be to get its salary cap in order, "to make sure you can take up (recruiting) opportunities when they present themselves".

He played down the notion that the list would have a major overhaul. "The system doesn't allow you make that many changes," he said.

Miller described Richmond's total player payments situation as "reasonable" but added that the club would only enjoy sustained success if players eschewed "selfishness" in their financial demands. "You can't have it," he said of greedy players.

"You want players at your club who want to be involved in the next premiership at Richmond and they're the ones we'll keep."

He cited the Kangaroos and Brisbane as examples of clubs whose players had made financial sacrifices to prolong their team's period at the top.

"They didn't have outlandish demands," he said.

Miller acknowledged that the Tigers had overrated their list at the end of 2001, when the team finished third and then topped up the list with Paul Hudson and Adam Houlihan.

He said the recruiting that followed 2001 indicated the Tigers believed themselves "closer (to a premiership) than they possibly were".

Miller's comments are consistent with his role as an objective internal critic at Richmond.

"They employed me to come and give an assessment of where the club was up to," he said. "That's happened and the board's been very supportive."

Miller also reiterated his message to the Richmond supporters that the club's resurgence would "take time" and required patience. He said that despite recent defeats, the Tigers had made "giant inroads" on a more successful future.
 

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,348
31
Gus would you mind editing your post to include the source please. It's to protect against the possibility of legal action, as well as a courtesy to anyone who might wish to look up the original article.
Thanks. :)
 

gustiger12

Its Tiger Time
Jan 22, 2003
9,933
2
www.thaigerpics.com
Hows that Rosy.

The Legal Action argument is an interesting one, but wouldn't like to rely on that as protection though Rosy.

With the Internet etc it is a very complicated issue.

Maybe JohnF could provide a "learned Opinion"
 

Rampaging_Richo

Making the easy seem incredible
Dec 19, 2002
1,167
0
Melbourne
I have been lucky enough to have seen the page which talks about players to delist/retire/trade.

It says "refer to page 2 which details Richmond Football Club player list 2003" ;D ;D
 

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,348
31
Thanks Gus,

Copying articles was an issue raised by the AFL several months ago, and posted on the boards by mellowyellow.

If anyone wanted to take action I doubt naming sources would be much protection really, but it's better to name them just the same imo.

It can't hurt anyway, and I think it's appropriate give a bit of a plug to the original source too.
 

JohnF

LMFAOOO
Mar 29, 2003
1,039
0
gustiger12 said:
The Legal Action argument is an interesting one, but wouldn't like to rely on that as protection though Rosy.

With the Internet etc it is a very complicated issue.

Maybe JohnF could provide a "learned Opinion"

Sorry folks, intellectual property law is an elective in the bachelor of laws degree I am doing, and I'm sticking clear of it! I'm always useless when it comes to legal matters. Friends always come up to me with legal concerns asking me what to do, and I can never provide anything useful. (Very irritating i can imagine to my friends involved). LOL, if i was a laywer i'd be exactly like that guy in "The Castle". I'd stand up and say "it's the vibe, it's the law, it's Mabo" LMAO!

Luckily my sister has studied it, and she should know quite a bit about it, might ask her what exactly is involved.

In the meantime, if you are really interested, here's a link to an article which I think will be helpful

http://www.law.gov.au/www/securitylawHome.nsf/Web+Pages/DDE9E530E5D5ADD6CA256B8900079356?OpenDocument


Haven't read it by the way. I'm too lazy even for that!
 

Laff

September showers
Dec 19, 2002
1,282
2
Hopefully Miller had a frank and honest look at the coaching and who is to blame for the position we find our selves in. Cut the list agreed but whats the point of a fifth year coach going back to the beggining and starting again....cut that dud now
 

Rosy

Tiger Legend
Mar 27, 2003
54,348
31
JohnF said:
LOL, if i was a laywer i'd be exactly like that guy in "The Castle". I'd stand up and say "it's the vibe, it's the law, it's Mabo" LMAO!

It's in the constitution. ;D

Somehow I don't think Denis DeNito woudl get past the spell checker here, ha.

(P.S. I'm too lazy to read the article too. If it's relevant and I could lose my house I hope someone lets me know what it says.)
 

JohnF

LMFAOOO
Mar 29, 2003
1,039
0
LMAo, yeah how incompetent , I can't even spell lawyer correctly. Can't wait to open up a firm on Sydney rd.
 

JohnF

LMFAOOO
Mar 29, 2003
1,039
0
rosy3 said:
(P.S. I'm too lazy to read the article too. If it's relevant and I could lose my house I hope someone lets me know what it says.)

Just from a common sense standpoint rosy, i can't see what the payoff would be of dragging something like this through court. If it does get to that I'd be looking to argue that the articles don't really constitute intellectual property, as they are written by people who wouldn't have a clue. ;D