Re: jake carlisle

[IanG]

Why are there clearly posts missing in this thread from the last 12 hours or so when they obviously relate to something that has already appeared in the media?

 

[Tigers of Old]

Good question Ian.

 

[seven]

The government is hiding the truth.

 

[Rosy]

Why are there clearly posts missing in this thread from the last 12 hours or so when they obviously relate to something that has already appeared in the media?

Good question Ian.

I'd appreciate you both telling me which posts are clearly missing in this thread.

 

[Tigers of Old]

I started a thread yesterday re the ACA vision. That post has disappeared.

 

[tha8ball]

I started a thread yesterday re the ACA vision. That post has disappeared.

Mine too

 

[Rosy]

That doesn't explain why you think asking about "posts clearly missing from this thread" is a "good question". It's not the first time IanG has made false claims in regard to the moderating of this site. You know well that the posts referred to weren't on this thread.

Your thread was titled "Football scandal?" You didn't mention Jake Carlisle and at that stage he hadn't been publicly named as far as I could find. It had nothing whatsoever to do with this thread. People were speculating and naming others with claims about drug taking. That's not fair on the players and it puts PRE at risk of potential legal action. If you have issues with it being removed that's your problem. I'm not willing to risk it.

There was no discussion whatsoever on this thread about Jake's situation. Not one word unless you claim Timmy's "WOW". You both could have sent a private message to ask what had become of the other thread. If accusations are going to be made publicly they should at least be factual. :

 

[Rosy]

Mine too

As has every post on that thread. The thread was removed.

 

[Rosy]

For what it's worth ToO this was the post on the new thread you started. Nothing about Carlisle. You invited speculation about players.

Yeah another one. ;D
Apparently according to Ch9's A Current Despair, some 'star' player's got into hot water on a holiday and been videoed.
Have to wait and see who/what it is.

Any ideas? ;D

 

[Tigers of Old]

Yep that's it.

 

[Rosy]

Yep that's it.

Yep. And for IanG's sake...it wasn't on the thread he was referring to and it wasn't about a player who had been referred to in the media (or on PRE) at that stage.

 

[IanG]

I'd appreciate you both telling me which posts are clearly missing in this thread.

This post appears to be referring to a post that isn't in the thread:

Solid work on ACA Snakey.

Comes out on the day of the trade.

What a time to be alive.

That doesn't explain why you think asking about "posts clearly missing from this thread" is a "good question". It's not the first time IanG has made false claims in regard to the moderating of this site. You know well that the posts referred to weren't on this thread.

Rosy you imply I'm being deliberately malicious, I was just asking a question and if I've made erroneous claims about moderation before then they are simple mistakes.

 

[Rosy]

This post appears to be referring to a post that isn't in the thread:

......

So you made the claim based on a post appearing to be referring to something that isn't in the thread? Rather than posts you actually read you assume others were removed because you can't see what another post was referring to? Fair dinkum.

Fact is there were zero posts "clearly missing" from that thread as you claimed.
It's not the first time you've been wrong when publicly questioning moderating on this site. In future a PM would be appreciated rather than misleading people.

 

[IanG]

So you made the claim based on a post appearing to be referring to something that isn't in the thread? Rather than posts you actually read you assume others were removed because you can't see what another post was referring to? Fair dinkum.

Fact is there were zero posts "clearly missing" from that thread as you claimed.
It's not the first time you've been wrong when publicly questioning moderating on this site. In future a PM would be appreciated rather than misleading people.

Rosy I asked a question thats all, if I'm wrong and came across too stridently I apologise. It was a simple mistake.