P
PuntRoadRoar
Guest
Stayers:
1. Justin Blumfield- haven’t seen enough of him to judge, maybe make the bench of a decent 22
2. Joel Bowden- with our current crop is one of our best players but disappears when it matters the most
3. Wayne Campbell- worthy of our jumper, a priveledge to watch
4. Mark Chaffey – hard nut who needs more support, definite inclusion.
5. Mark Coughlan- good kid with plenty to offer and support our midfield
6. Darren Gaspar – our best backman, but overpaid
7. Ben Holland – another injury prone player, liked what I saw a few seasons ago as a backman but over paid.
8. Kane Johnson – I like him, needs support atm, offers hope.
9. Andrew Kellaway – I like him as a backman, gives 100%
10. Andrew Krakouer – finally someone who will offer us hope. Shown enough to keep me happy and will only get better.
11. Chris Newman – definite stayer, this kid has a lot to offer.
12. Brad Ottens – love him but needs support, someone to build a team around him
13. Matthew Richardson – one of our best players but when it counts doesn’t deliver. Too inconsistent, frustrating, would keep him but borderline.
14. David Rodan – stayer, he would be in my team, like his agility and is a possible match winner
15. Jay Schulz – don’t know never seen him play, good raps, would keep him from what I hear, maybe a future replacement for richo?
16. Greg Stafford – staying, provides Richmond with options with a fit ottens
17. Greg Tivendale – stay, last year very disappointing but has shown a lot more consistency this year.
18. Ty Zantuck – to stay, need some players who have a dip but can dispose of the ball under pressure, still a lot to learn.
Border line
1.Duncan Kellaway – I think he was great, but injury prone, I think he needs to call it a day.
2.Martin McGrath – haven’t seen him, sounded impressive early but lacks discipline from what I hear, but can he play? If not then shouldn’t on the list.
3.Marc Dragicevic – been too long out of it, 2 recon’s will he worth it? Personally I think he has to go
Time to go:
Craig Biddiscombe – time to go, is a bit player not good enough to make the 22
Leon Cameron – would have to be his last season, very good at rebounding but that’s about it.
Aaron Fiora – very disappointing, for so much expectations, has to be given the boot
Tim Fleming – likes to go in hard once, but doubt very much if theres quality, I know why he never got a game with the blues
Ray Hall – just not good enough, lacks consistency
Rory Hilton – lost a bit of heart since he lost a bit of his shoulder, not good enough these days, never had any skill.
Adam Houlihan – time to go, try’s to do the special thing instead of the right thing, too fancy. Chris Hyde – never paid him enough attention, does he play? Or not good enough perhaps?
Clinton King – never liked him never will, should be the first to go, for a possession onballer doesn’t get the ball often and when he gets it is a crap kick, not big enough to be a in and under player with heart like dunc, chaffy etc.
Andrew Mills – another who I haven’t paid much attention 2, is it because he hasn’t been given a go or maybe just not good enough
Bill Nicholls – been injured and in reserves most of the year, haven’t seen enough, same old story as the others
Kane Pettifer – not good enough, need players who can get the pill and deliver when it counts most
Matthew Rogers – time to go matty, was good service but is now becoming too slow and being exposed too often
Daniel Sipthorp – don’t know never seen him play.
Royce Vardy – I don’t think he would be in most 22’s on that theory its time to go
1. Justin Blumfield- haven’t seen enough of him to judge, maybe make the bench of a decent 22
2. Joel Bowden- with our current crop is one of our best players but disappears when it matters the most
3. Wayne Campbell- worthy of our jumper, a priveledge to watch
4. Mark Chaffey – hard nut who needs more support, definite inclusion.
5. Mark Coughlan- good kid with plenty to offer and support our midfield
6. Darren Gaspar – our best backman, but overpaid
7. Ben Holland – another injury prone player, liked what I saw a few seasons ago as a backman but over paid.
8. Kane Johnson – I like him, needs support atm, offers hope.
9. Andrew Kellaway – I like him as a backman, gives 100%
10. Andrew Krakouer – finally someone who will offer us hope. Shown enough to keep me happy and will only get better.
11. Chris Newman – definite stayer, this kid has a lot to offer.
12. Brad Ottens – love him but needs support, someone to build a team around him
13. Matthew Richardson – one of our best players but when it counts doesn’t deliver. Too inconsistent, frustrating, would keep him but borderline.
14. David Rodan – stayer, he would be in my team, like his agility and is a possible match winner
15. Jay Schulz – don’t know never seen him play, good raps, would keep him from what I hear, maybe a future replacement for richo?
16. Greg Stafford – staying, provides Richmond with options with a fit ottens
17. Greg Tivendale – stay, last year very disappointing but has shown a lot more consistency this year.
18. Ty Zantuck – to stay, need some players who have a dip but can dispose of the ball under pressure, still a lot to learn.
Border line
1.Duncan Kellaway – I think he was great, but injury prone, I think he needs to call it a day.
2.Martin McGrath – haven’t seen him, sounded impressive early but lacks discipline from what I hear, but can he play? If not then shouldn’t on the list.
3.Marc Dragicevic – been too long out of it, 2 recon’s will he worth it? Personally I think he has to go
Time to go:
Craig Biddiscombe – time to go, is a bit player not good enough to make the 22
Leon Cameron – would have to be his last season, very good at rebounding but that’s about it.
Aaron Fiora – very disappointing, for so much expectations, has to be given the boot
Tim Fleming – likes to go in hard once, but doubt very much if theres quality, I know why he never got a game with the blues
Ray Hall – just not good enough, lacks consistency
Rory Hilton – lost a bit of heart since he lost a bit of his shoulder, not good enough these days, never had any skill.
Adam Houlihan – time to go, try’s to do the special thing instead of the right thing, too fancy. Chris Hyde – never paid him enough attention, does he play? Or not good enough perhaps?
Clinton King – never liked him never will, should be the first to go, for a possession onballer doesn’t get the ball often and when he gets it is a crap kick, not big enough to be a in and under player with heart like dunc, chaffy etc.
Andrew Mills – another who I haven’t paid much attention 2, is it because he hasn’t been given a go or maybe just not good enough
Bill Nicholls – been injured and in reserves most of the year, haven’t seen enough, same old story as the others
Kane Pettifer – not good enough, need players who can get the pill and deliver when it counts most
Matthew Rogers – time to go matty, was good service but is now becoming too slow and being exposed too often
Daniel Sipthorp – don’t know never seen him play.
Royce Vardy – I don’t think he would be in most 22’s on that theory its time to go
