2007 Player of the year threads [Merged]

Rosy · Apr 13, 2007

PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

Place your 3,2,1 votes after the game.

Harry · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

where's the tally?

Disco08 · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

Here

mk33 · Apr 13, 2007

Re: 2007 PRE Player of the Year-Rd 2 vs Swans

Tigers of Old said:
Nice work Pants.

I like the formatting. Very sophisticated. 8)

agree looks great and good report

top stuff Panth

an_oxford_man · Apr 13, 2007

Loving you work, Panthera. Keep it up, bro.

jb03 · Apr 13, 2007

Gypsy__Jazz said:
Loving you work, Panthera. Keep it up, bro.

Agree, oustanding Panth

Freezer · Apr 13, 2007

Just a question on the voting system - as most PREnders are more likely to get to Richmond games at the G (this is purely an assumption) and hence more likely to be able to cast votes in those rounds, does this mean these games are more likely to attract high volume votes? If 25 PREnders attend tonight's game against Collingwood and all give 3 votes to one player (totalling 75 votes), but only 5 get to our next game at Subiaco and give 3 votes to another player (15 votes), does this give a true indication of who had the better game?

I'm just wondering if the number of votes cast should be limited to the same number each week - say the first 20 people to vote, meaning all games are equally weighted.

Perhaps this is already done; it was just something I thought of while reading this thread.

jb03 · Apr 13, 2007

Freezer said:
Just a question on the voting system - as most PREnders are more likely to get to Richmond games at the G (this is purely an assumption) and hence more likely to be able to cast votes in those rounds, does this mean these games are more likely to attract high volume votes? If 25 PREnders attend tonight's game against Collingwood and all give 3 votes to one player (totalling 75 votes), but only 5 get to our next game at Subiaco and give 3 votes to another player (15 votes), does this give a true indication of who had the better game?

I'm just wondering if the number of votes cast should be limited to the same number each week - say the first 20 people to vote, meaning all games are equally weighted.

Perhaps this is already done; it was just something I thought of while reading this thread.

You're proabably right Freezer but that's just the way it goes. If you want to be the PRE B&F, play well at home games at the 'G. OF course, people still vote off watching the games on TV so I'm sure it all balances out. PRE has a pretty good track record at identifying the Richmond B&F placings (except for last your I think)

Coughlan24 · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

3 - Foley (Outstanding again)

2 - Johnson

1 - Pattison

SfB_AkA._DeLiCiOuS · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

3-Foley

2-Deledio

1-Schulz

Ms Tantie · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

3 - Weeble Foley
2 - Sergeant Schulz
1 - Rambling Tambling

:'(

Ms Tantie.
xox

Scoop · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

3 O Bree
2 Dane Swan
1 Lockyer.

None of them had a man all nite.

For the losers.

3 Foley
2 Tambling
1 Lids.

And someone gave Pattison a vote!!!

tannerztigers · Apr 13, 2007

Re: PRE Player of the Year-Rd 3 vs Collingwood

3 - Foley

2 - Deledio

1 - Tambling

Also Scultz, Tivendale (again) and Johnson were good

tannerztigers · Apr 13, 2007