Disco08 said:3. Murphy - completely dominant
2. Gibbs - Unstop
3 - Richo
2 - Morton
1 - Tambling
Dyer Disciple said:3 - Morton (Was laughing all night about people posting on here he can't mark above his head, he is soft, etc etc)
2 - McGuane (We may have been looking at another 4 or 5 goals added to Carlton's score without him, played his guts out and smart)
1 - Foley (Looked proppy early, felt he was struggling on ankle. Really showed he has passion for the club and worked his way into the game)
I'm staggered some on here have given Tambling, Simmo or Lids (who I all like so not potting them) votes as they were atrocious at times and ordinary at their best.
Tambling looked lost and hesitant, Simmo was beaten all night save for some float back and mark in defence easy plays and Lids was well and truly taken out of the game for the most part by Carlton and even did some uncharacteristic sloppy decision making due to the intense pressure.
McMahon was the worst player by a mile. At the ground and watching him off camera the positions he ran to and way he shirked contests was disgusting.
jannisarie said:I had taken my girlfriends Irish parents to thier first footy game while they are over visiting and I bought them all richmond scarfs to make sure none of them defect but I don't think it will help.
jannisarie said:I was trying to explain who our best players where before the match. I was having issues pointing them out during.
B1 and B2 said:1. Cousins (because he actually hit a target with a footpass)
B1
GoodOne said:1. Foley - feel sorry for a guy who puts his body on the line in and under and has no-one to run with him.