Paddy Naish - where is he at?

[Number8]

Was the only Tiger with multiple tackles in the first quarter.

 

[Tigers2011]

awful attempt to tackle on HFF that led to the blonde rabbits goal.....unacceptable with the game in the balance

Spot on. Game was over from that moment.

 

[tassietiger12]

should be delisted tomorrow

 

[bigwow]

awful attempt to tackle on HFF that led to the blonde rabbits goal.....unacceptable with the game in the balance

Yep, that was the game right there. He was good in patches, but carried along by the others, in the periods of the game we were up. Downhill skier?

 

[RoarEmotion]

Still a very slight frame but he is definitely tougher at the ball than he used to be. Just not sure he will have good enough strength levels to compete in a contest.

Clicked on this thread and this was first post that came up for me.
you hit the nail on the head.

 

[RUNVS]

He (Naish) like Ross and RCD are just not up to it. At least Stack and Parker would have put their bodies on the line.

 

[St Kevin]

VFA level footballer. Soft.

 

[MD Jazz]

Never ever ever again. Arguably Cost us the game. Will do it again. Soft soft soft. Simply not up to AFzl intensity.

 

[MD Jazz]

Far from the worst

?????? Awful.

 

[Tigers2011]

Horrible, horrible non commitment to both the ball and man

Spot on - quite a few times where he just doesn’t attack the contest. Can’t be elite AFL & do that. Missed tackle was just awful - weak & insipid. Delist or trade. He’s done.

 

[Merveille]

Spot on - quite a few times where he just doesn’t attack the contest. Can’t be elite AFL & do that. Missed tackle was just awful - weak & insipid. Delist or trade. He’s done.

 

[Merveille]

GC last goal. Watch his positioning on Ainsworth who crumbs it and gives it to King. Gave him 10 metres then did a half jump in marking contest while Ainsworth sat in the clear 5 metres on his own at front of pack. Never seen anything like it - but why oh why was he on Ainsworth?

 

[dimmauchamp]

Still cant understand how you can be in the AFL system for 4 years and still not expect any physical contact

 

[Number8]

Some emotional posting here. I get it.

But this bloke hasn't even played 10 games of footy.

Much bigger problems elsewhere.

 

[Jason King]

I just want the ball in his hands more. He is a really good user but he doesn't do enough to get the pill.

 

[Ridley]

Far from the worst

Sorry Scoop I know you’re a fan but Paddy is done. Clearly not up to it; has shown nothing every time he’s been given an opportunity. Too slight; not strong enough and not good enough to make up for those deficiencies.

 

[King Kong]

Houli and Naish - never seen 2 players avoid body contact as much as they do.

 

[The_General]

Some emotional posting here. I get it.

But this bloke hasn't even played 10 games of footy.

Much bigger problems elsewhere.

This. Anyone expect a kid taken in the 30's to just step up to AFL level in his first dozen games? Most first round picks don't do it.
I remember people saying ditch Rance after his chaotic beginning. People need to take some emotion out of this. He was one of only a few to hit the scoreboard in the first half.

 

[seven]

One of our better players
In hindsight, good selection

 

[St Kevin]

This. Anyone expect a kid taken in the 30's to just step up to AFL level in his first dozen games? Most first round picks don't do it.
I remember people saying ditch Rance after his chaotic beginning. People need to take some emotion out of this. He was one of only a few to hit the scoreboard in the first half.

There are non-negotiables at AFL level re physicality and Naish can’t/won’t do them. Rance never had that problem, you always knew he was trying his arse off.