Depends. If you want defensive effort, go George. You want goal scoring potential, you go Cumberland.For those that watched, would you go Cumberland or Castagna in the forwards?
Depends. If you want defensive effort, go George. You want goal scoring potential, you go Cumberland.For those that watched, would you go Cumberland or Castagna in the forwards?
I'm a George semi-fan he won't be loosing his spot to Cumberland any time soon even though Noah was great today.For those that watched, would you go Cumberland or Castagna in the forwards?
As someone at the other end of the axis, why not?I'm a George semi-fan he won't be loosing his spot to Cumberland any time soon even though Noah was great today.
Because George is a triple premiership player has had another good pre-season has the aerobic capacity to run up and down the ground even if it can be chaotic. He is a good mark for his size and kicks goals as well as misses them.As someone at the other end of the axis, why not?
Dusty for sure.If any from today's 2's game play, who from today's Hawks game would miss out?
If any from today's 2's game play, who from today's Hawks game would miss out?
Great assessment…at match committee I don’t think George is one of the ones they are discussing if he keeps his spot…he had a bad patch last year and got dropped what was it for 1 week?Because George is a triple premiership player has had another good pre-season has the aerobic capacity to run up and down the ground even if it can be chaotic. He is a good mark for his size and kicks goals as well as misses them.
Cumberland has had two good games that i have seen, he also is a good mark and can tackle hard but be can be a bit undisciplined. I reckon his kicking can also be hit and miss similar to George and doesn't have the aerobic capacity yet to get up the ground.
It is George's to lose and I don't think he does.
bit rough on caddy, still reckon he has a lot to offer. reckon theres a spot on the bench as a Mr Handyman.I have edited my initial post Caddy deserved to be in my top 5 today but no longer the AFL side IMO.
Good comments on RCD showing leadership qualities too.Cumberland and Stack rise as Richmond overcomes Box Hill in practice match
Richmond VFL defeated Box Hill by 14 points in a practice match at the Swinburne Centre on Saturday morning.www.richmondfc.com.au
Great news on Sonz & Stack. If there's any players we wanted to do well yesterday it's them. Cheers C.I was there and saw whole game, my best in order:
1) Sonz
2) 100% Effort by Syd today
Great Work Caesar ....HailI was there and saw whole game, my best in order:
1) Sonz
2) 100% Effort by Syd today
3) Cumberland
4) Parker
5) Dow
**Edit: Caddy deserves to be in my top 5 today but no longer the AFL side IMO.
VFL player number 14 is a ripper.
Caesar how far off do out think Sonsie is from an AFL debut?Cumberland and Stack rise as Richmond overcomes Box Hill in practice match
Richmond VFL defeated Box Hill by 14 points in a practice match at the Swinburne Centre on Saturday morning.www.richmondfc.com.au
First match I have seen Sonsie play so too early for me to really say after one low level VFL practice match, he is further advanced than I thought considering his delayed preparation.Caesar how far off do out think Sonsie is from an AFL debut?
These 3 need to step up this year for us to go places.Miller was a little disappointing for mine, Dow started a bit slowly but worked into the game and was my 5th best, Riley was reasonably quiet.
As someone at the other end of the axis, why not?