Real sorry to see Big Ivan go but good luck to the guy and hope it all works out for him at Adelaide. However, I thing it was a wrong move to lose the only big ruckman we have as Nanks has trouble with some opposition and Ryan hasn't the bulk or the nous yet. Mind you Ivan was part of the deal to get Jacob so win some and lose some
I think the main thing is the club does have back-up and a promising young ruck who could become a star when he bulks up more along with obtaining the greater experience he needs - from getting further exposure and opportunities.
It seemed the club wanted to keep big Eevan initially too unless those statements were just designed to up the ante for PA. I agreed initially too for the same reasons the club and many of us on here expressed. But now, for similar reasons that many others alternative views have said so well, I'm all in favour. this was a great deal for Soldo; the club effectively turned lead into some gold over his whole development and trade. And Eevan deserves to finish his career seeing if he can reach his full potential, perhaps becoming another flag ruckman for them ... if he's up to it. They (PA) have a lot of other ducks in a row to win one in '24.
It should be remembered we also have Miller and Balta who can provide some chop-out for Ryan if he has to take on No.1 role if Nank goes down for any reason again. Plus, there's Colina and the young "Wolfman' if we got really desperate. Well, a big body to obstruct the oppo at least!
I sometimes get annoyed - still sour over the Butler 'giveaway' - but I have to respect our club's preparedness to not block a player's future ambitions and best interests, especially good citizens like these who have won flags with and for us.
But they are not stupid - there is back-up within the club's list in both cases - otherwise I'm sure they may have definitely held out against this Poort deal/offer.
But Ryan is the future. And sure, it's all potential so far, but the club again spotted a gangly young tall - playing in country Qld - they are seeking to develop into a possible A grade ruck who may ultimately become better than all our recent ruckmen: taller and faster, more mobile and athletic, a better mark who can go forward and clunk a pack mark, and a very impressive kick for distance and accuracy. He's even looking agile at ground level.
It's time for Samson Ryan.