2024 Draft Thread | PUNT ROAD END | Richmond Tigers Forum
  • IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.

2024 Draft Thread

Why draft so many speculative talls, Gray, Bauer, Fawcett and Lefau, then draft less speculative talls with high picks when midfielders were still available?
Allen may go home or not, if they do then we get paid well again in 3 years to let them go home.

Hindsight we should be drafting X factor with speed or maybe mature ruckmen with later picks and especially in mid season draft.

Otherwise we end up with an out of balance clogged list.
A good kpf is easily the most difficult position to find. If we nail 1 or 2 out of those then you can quickly build a team around that.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 4 users
Why draft so many speculative talls, Gray, Bauer, Fawcett and Lefau, then draft less speculative talls with high picks when midfielders were still available?
Allen may go home or not, if they do then we get paid well again in 3 years to let them go home.

Hindsight we should be drafting X factor with speed or maybe mature ruckmen with later picks and especially in mid season draft.

Otherwise we end up with an out of balance clogged list.
Because elite midfielders, Dyson Sharpe, Ollie Greeves and Dursma potentially available to us next year, yes there are a couple of promising talls next year too but the mids look certainties. In the mean time we will have had a year of development into Faull & Armstrong who could solve some forward problems?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 17 users
Wouldn't it be better to find a ready made early 20s ruckman instead of drafting a kid? We did it with Nank.
Sure we did it with Maric & Nank but that was when we were in that 5-8 bracket, we're not a destination club anymore, much better to grow our own in this current situation.
 
Be interesting to see what sort of offers we get for Pick 28 tomorrow.

You'd think the Bombers would be interested, but we don't have a lot to trade back, so just a straight trade for possible a top 10 pick next year? Not sure
If its the Swans or Geelong, maybe its a F1 plus 41 (Swans) or plus 42 (Geelong). I'd take those offers. Maybe St Kilda, would we take F1 and 51? Probably.

I reckon Brisbane will trade a few picks out of this draft too, not sure who has the list spots, but they still have 5 picks I think, and I doubt they have that many list spots remaining.
I am not sure if i am being unrealistic, but i would hope to trade the 1st pick for maybe Power F1 and their next pick- about 34, then trade that to the Cats for their F1 and their next pick (or no next pick. both those teams would be hoping for top 4 at least so they would be giving away about pick 20. If there are players they want they might bite.
I would almost prefer this than say the Bombers F1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Because elite midfielders, Dyson Sharpe, Ollie Greeves and Dursma potentially available to us next year, yes there are a couple of promising talls next year too but the mids look certainties. In the mean time we will have had a year of development into Faull & Armstrong who could solve some forward problems?
Add Tom Burton to that list,he was impressive in the game l seen him in .
It is quite Compromised though next year,with academy player's,even the Magpies have a good F/S in Mcguane.
 
  • Like
  • Love
Reactions: 1 users
Dodson,Jack Whitlock,Shanahan ,Moraes,,Gerryn,Sims,Jaques,Archer day Wicks,Alger,Davis,Boxshall,Ivisic,,Sulzberger,,,O Farrel,Mraz,Gross,,Ough,,Barrat,,Burmeister.

Still quite a bit of talent left , and next year is very compromised,

I am really really hoping the AFL tighten the screws on academy / NGA / freebies next year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
Sure we did it with Maric & Nank but that was when we were in that 5-8 bracket, we're not a destination club anymore, much better to grow our own in this current situation.
I reckon we still are. Last night's kids' expressions showed it with our premiership players presenting and spreading the word.....like passing the baton. I've always wanted to grow our own in ruck but it has been a failure since General Lee.....a long, long time ago.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user
I am not sure if i am being unrealistic, but i would hope to trade the 1st pick for maybe Power F1 and their next pick- about 34, then trade that to the Cats for their F1 and their next pick (or no next pick. both those teams would be hoping for top 4 at least so they would be giving away about pick 20. If there are players they want they might bite.
I would almost prefer this than say the Bombers F1.

Gold Coast have Ports F1.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Today it's Jack Whitlock versus Dodson, I'll be happy with either, we might even be able to have our cake and eat it by trading our day 2 pick, shuffling down the order and picking up 1 of these guys in the late second round.

I can't see us taking any more KP players, possibly a ruck, but not even sure we will do that.

Last season we started with 13 KPP's (including rucks - including the 2 Cat B's). We ended with 15 (as we added Blight and Gray and we currently have 15 on the list.

Any more, and we create a big list imbalance. Almost certain the last 2 on our list with either be mids or smalls.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 6 users
I am not sure if i am being unrealistic, but i would hope to trade the 1st pick for maybe Power F1 and their next pick- about 34, then trade that to the Cats for their F1 and their next pick (or no next pick. both those teams would be hoping for top 4 at least so they would be giving away about pick 20. If there are players they want they might bite.
I would almost prefer this than say the Bombers F1.
Am hoping for something similar but with the bombers. Their F1 and 37 for 28 which will give them Shanahan which by all accounts they are pretty keen on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 users
Im pretty sure @bengal tigers and Blair Hartley were twins separated at birth.

Blair got polished by a sports finishing school at harvard,

While Bengal sheltered from the sleet under the grandstand at the Northern Oval, Ballarat, reared by a cabal of over-sized wild ferrets who escaped from a football family. Possibly The Locketts or Malthouses would be my guess?

I know for a fact they bred the same wily strain of warren warrior weasels, in parallel, even sharing bucks.

Its got netflix written all over it
Early days Blair actually worked in the meat department of the old Safeway in Eltham as a butcher.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: 1 user
Because elite midfielders, Dyson Sharpe, Ollie Greeves and Dursma potentially available to us next year, yes there are a couple of promising talls next year too but the mids look certainties. In the mean time we will have had a year of development into Faull & Armstrong who could solve some forward problems?
Greeves is a bit of a Smillie clone though. Don't think we need another of that type.
 
Because elite midfielders, Dyson Sharpe, Ollie Greeves and Dursma potentially available to us next year, yes there are a couple of promising talls next year too but the mids look certainties. In the mean time we will have had a year of development into Faull & Armstrong who could solve some forward problems?
I like that explanation mate. I'm a bit clueless when it comes to all the draft shenanigans, (some might even say I'm clueless when it comes to most things!)
So I put my trust (and hope) in those whose job, is to do their job.👍
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
The points system changes next year l think ,and the discounts are reduced ,,so clubs might have to keep their first rounders .
I know its been beaten to death but if it aint father son there should be no reason why clubs dont have to pay actual worth in draft picks for these players. Whether its next years or the years after F1, F2 etc then so be it. Marshall was exactly what we needed yet wasnt available and we basically owned the first round.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 users
I am not sure if i am being unrealistic, but i would hope to trade the 1st pick for maybe Power F1 and their next pick- about 34, then trade that to the Cats for their F1 and their next pick (or no next pick. both those teams would be hoping for top 4 at least so they would be giving away about pick 20. If there are players they want they might bite.
I would almost prefer this than say the Bombers F1.

Port don't have a F1, but I like the idea.

I think it could be something like:

Hawks F1 and 35 for 28
Then
Geelong F1 and 42 for 35

Maybe I'm being too unrealistic too, but that would put us in a great position.

An alternative could be something like

Saints F2 and 32 for 28
Then
Geelong F1 and 42 for 35

Not too much difference in there unless the Saints jump right up the ladder, but both good outcomes for us. The next group that are expected to be drafted are talls and we now have a lot on our list, and we need to either play them in either the AFL or VFL sides, so can't see us drafting any more, otherwise we run the risk of stunting their development by not being able to play them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user