Changes V Eagles

[AstuteTiger]

I reckon we will only get Lambert now every other game, so reckon he plays next week.

In: Cotch, Lambert, Stack, Cumberland
Out: Prestia, Shedda, Clarke, HRS, Gibcus

Soldo into the starting 22 (though I wouldn't be against giving Ryan a run) and Shedda as the sub. I don't think we need the extra tall down back against the Eagles. Tarrant on Kennedy, Grimes or Broad on Darling, Vlastuin and the remaining one of Broad / Grimes to deal with Waterman and the resting ruck.

Id keep hugo in. Do we need to go a 2nd ruckman? Soldo doesn't offer much around the ground. If its balta fine, as he can play forward and is quick and mobile.
Samson Ryan is tracking well, I rate him.

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

Is Nat Nit Nat patty whack back this week.
He would sooo under done.
I would select Sampson instead of soldo.

 

[AstuteTiger]

Is Nat Nit Nat patty whack back this week.
He would sooo under done.
I would select Sampson instead of soldo.

Wouldnt be concerned if he did play but I doubt it as he would be severely underdone.

 

[seven]

We need:
One of the following, but all 3 would be great

Bears beat Dogs
Bummers beat Swans
Suns beat pies

 

[Rantnrave]

After watching today's VFL, Both or one of these two below need to come in to replace Clarke. Id also have Miller come in to replace Gibcus

Stack - 16 disposals, 1 goal and 8 tackles
Cumberland - 15 disposals, 4 goals
Notable mentions to Aarts 23 disposals and 2 goals and Castagna 3 goals and 9 tackles.

OUTS: Clarke, Gibcus, Prestia (concussion)
INS: Cotchin or Lambert if fit. Stack or Cumberland, Miller

Our lack of chase and tackle in the foward zone makes me favor both castagna and stack.....sadly edwards must be sub at best and rest clark..

 

[AstuteTiger]

Our lack of chase and tackle in the foward zone makes me favor both castagna and stack.....sadly edwards must be sub at best and rest clark..

I think Clarke is going to be a beauty but geez if dimma had him in to pressure he didn't do it and didn't lay one tackle.
Stack or Cumberland a must. Even Castagna, but id have him after Stack and Cumberland at this present time.

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

I can't believe how many people want King George back.

 

[craig]

We need:
One of the following, but all 3 would be great

Bears beat Dogs
Bummers beat Swans
Suns beat pies

Big chance of two of those.

Bears at home can beat Dogs and Suns definitely can beat the skunks at Mertricon.

 

[Tenacious]

I can't believe how many people want King George back.

They’re the remaining members of the cult that you brainwashed with your incessant praise of him over the past few years

 

[bricci]

Think we need to save Balta and Lambert for the Gold Coast game, regardless of their fitness. We should also consider giving Nank a rest. If not this one maybe against North when Balta is back. Mansell to the backline to release Baker to the midfield. Stack takes Clarkes' place. Like others I think Cumberland needs a chance, even though this is a forward for a back swap.

In: Cotch, Stack, Cumberland, Mansell
Out: Prestia, Gibcus, Clarke, Ralph-Smith

B: Grimes Tarrant Broad
HB: DRioli Vlastuin Mansell
C: Pickett Short McIntosh
HF: Graham Martin Bolton
F: Riewoldt Lynch MRioli
R: Nankervis Cotchin Baker
I: Soldo Stack Ross Cumberland
S: Ralph-Smith

 

[T-Shirt Tommy]

End the Cumberland farce.

 

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

If Cotch needs another week, WCE is the perfect game for Sonsie to debut, replacing Prestia. Stack or Cumbo for Clarke.

 

[year of the tiger]

Think we need to save Balta and Lambert for the Gold Coast game, regardless of their fitness. We should also consider giving Nank a rest. If not this one maybe against North when Balta is back. Mansell to the backline to release Baker to the midfield. Stack takes Clarkes' place. Like others I think Cumberland needs a chance, even though this is a forward for a back swap.

In: Cotch, Stack, Cumberland, Mansell
Out: Prestia, Gibcus, Clarke, Ralph-Smith

B: Grimes Tarrant Broad
HB: DRioli Vlastuin Mansell
C: Pickett Short McIntosh
HF: Graham Martin Bolton
F: Riewoldt Lynch MRioli
R: Nankervis Cotchin Baker
I: Soldo Stack Ross Cumberland
S: Ralph-Smith

I agree with your first 3 ins and 3 outs, yet to be convinced of your last one though, and Dimma doesn’t often do 4 changes to a team that is playing well.

 

[Tigerfan]

Out Prestia
In Cumberland

On ice: Balta lambert Cotchin Prestia

 

[Smoking Aces]

Stack has to come in for Clarke.

 

[Tigerfan]

Grimes. Tarrant short
Rioli Gibcus Vlastuin
Mcintosh. Pickett Broad
Bolton. Riewoldt edwards
Moz Jnr. Lynch. Martin

Nankervis Ross. Baker
Soldo ralphsmith Graeme Cumberland
Sub: Clarke

 

[Ghost of 29]

Out: Prestia, Judson
In: Stack, Cumberland

But ins will most likely be Lambert and Cotchy

 

[TigerMasochist]

Reckon it might be time for
Stacky for Prestygiocomo.
Cummerbund to replace Shedda.
Delilah for a proper look instead of Soldo.
Millerlight to rest Gibber.

Rushing either Cotchinator, Lamblett or Balta back early is bloody risky n I'd rather get more look at some of our young blokes.
Plenty of our older champions have been struggling all year n it's a large part of why our season has been so patchy. The future is rushing down on us quicker than we might have anticipated n we need to give the young blokes the chance to step into next year n beyond.

 

[T-Shirt Tommy]

End the Cumbo farce.

Baker to replace Dion in the midfield.
Stack to replace Baker in defence.
Cumbo to replace Clarke forward.

 

[Tiger Pops]

Its a we just rock up and win mentality danger game. We see teams play poorly but when they get a number of their stars back they go out (finish the season) with a bang.

Beware the team that has nothing to loose. I also feel that the abysmal North will save its best for Richmond as well !!!