Paddy Naish - where is he at?

[gehring]

Have to strongly disagree struts like a champion but 80% of his kicks went astray, under pressure has no physical presence. Will not make it and needs to be replaced at years end. Its time for a rebuild as others have stated. There are some that will not be AFL but can keep to support and protect the newbies (morris, Garth, caddy) those with attitude. Where is our next full forward, CHF, Full Back CHB? completely missing in the seconds where we are plugging gaps with ruckmen.
On a sour note I watched the AFL academy play Geelong 2nds and did not see a player over 194cm that looked to have any KPP stand out talent. Perhaps some of the U19's may fit the bill?

 

[Harry]

Unfortunately don't think he suits our style of play

 

[Scoop]

He is built for modern game, need to give him a go.

I'm worried for my boy but I want to see him get a decent shot.

 

[bairdy380]

He is built for modern game, need to give him a go.

I'm worried for my boy but I want to see him get a decent shot.

Agree, but where scooper... he hasn’t shown the form to force a backline change. High half forward maybe? Can he read a game as a fwd or need it to unfold in front of him as a back?

 

[Bill Haverchuck]

The question after 4 years is he a highly fit two way runner now or still a bit of a one way kick chaser?
If the former give him a go...

 

[zippadeee]

Our version of Zac Guthrie

 

[King Kong]

Soft, outside turnover merchant........pass

 

[zippadeee]

Soft, outside turnover merchant........pass

A bit harsh little Kong.

 

[King Kong]

A bit harsh little Kong.

Watched the VFL game v Casey and he turned it over 3 times looking for short passes through the corridor. Cost us a goal each time

 

[TigerMad]

I have faith in Naish.
But he comes in and stays for three/four games.
May be used as a medical sub to build his confidence

 

[Dont Argue]

I have faith in Naish.
But he comes in and stays for three/four games.
May be used as a medical sub to build his confidence

Builds his confidence by playing him as the sub but destroy Ross’s confidence playing him as the sub?
I’m sub confused

 

[craig]

The sub rule is a load of *smile*.

They should only be there for replacement of a concussed player only!!

That way teams cant BS their way out of a 12 day holiday for whoever they swap out, as it must be for concussion and nothing else.

If you lose two blokes to ankle injuries thats bad luck

 

[TigerMad]

Builds his confidence by playing him as the sub but destroy Ross’s confidence playing him as the sub?
I’m sub confused

If Naish comes in against the doggies and plays a full game, he will be sore afterwards.
So maybe is the med sub the following week.
Then gets another full game the week after.

 

[wigglyworm]

If not now , when?

 

[jb03]

Looked spent when he came on

 

[year of the tiger]

Looked spent when he came on

Its a long time to sit on the bench.

That last tackle and pass to Bolton was gold.

He will make it.

 

[Tenacious]

If Naish comes in against the doggies and plays a full game, he will be sore afterwards.
So maybe is the med sub the following week.
Then gets another full game the week after.

You might be onto something here!

 

[Ghost of 29]

Its a long time to sit on the bench.

That last tackle and pass to Bolton was gold.

He will make it.

I think his team mates enjoyed his effort.

 

[BT Tiger]

I think his team mates enjoyed his effort.

Yep they really got around him after that.

 

[Sintiger]

Liked his game last night. 100% disposal efficiency