Rate our kids!!

[Leysy Days]

Agree. Difficult to make calls either way just yet. Some stuff I like, some not so much, some just meh.

Soft!!

 

[Smoking Aces]

The yearly "one to watch", didn't Redford have Stelly Green as last years version?

Be wary of the four-week predictions.



Judson behind a few is a shocking call. Kaleb Smith ahead of Judson? Hang on if Leysy thinks Judson is no good it's the reverse kiss of death!!

Your first mistake was listening to Redford.

Word has it that McAuliffe has impressed many at the club.

 

[tigerman]

Gibcus
Sonsie
Clarke
Banks
Brown
Cumberland
Campbell
Trezise
Ryan
Bauer

 

[Sintiger]

Gibcus has hamstring issues.
Brown has played 1 game in two seasons.
Sonsie went backwards & got suspended.
Clarke lost his spot in the team. Didn’t win much footy.
Samson also lost his spot in the side to Soldo.

I hate to be pessimistic but until proven otherwise there’s question marks on all of our kids.

 

[Midsy]

Reading through the list doesn’t exactly inspire confidence in the next 5 years.

 

[Tigers of Old]

View attachment 21384

Funny but I'm not sure what much I said was wrong. Time will ultimately tell how many make it.

 

[Sintiger]

Funny but I'm not sure what much I said was wrong. Time will ultimately tell how many make it.

It was a light hearted dig ... glass half empty vs glass half full. Truth is noone knows

Gibcus has hamstring issues but is young and showed enormous promise in 2022
Brown has played 1 game in two seasons mainly because of injury but looks calm and composed
Sonsie went backwards & got suspended but we know he can play at the level, we have seen it
Clarke lost his spot in the team. Didn’t win much footy but has all the tools to make it
Samson also lost his spot in the side to Soldo but is young in ruck terms and held his own when forced to ruck in 2023

 

[Tigers of Old]

It was a light hearted dig ... glass half empty vs glass half full. Truth is noone knows

Gibcus has hamstring issues but is young and showed enormous promise in 2022
Brown has played 1 game in two seasons mainly because of injury but looks calm and composed
Sonsie went backwards & got suspended but we know he can play at the level, we have seen it
Clarke lost his spot in the team. Didn’t win much footy but has all the tools to make it
Samson also lost his spot in the side to Soldo but is young in ruck terms and held his own when forced to ruck in 2023

Also all true. However for context, the original reply was in response to the assertion all would play 100 games. I agree nobody knows.

 

[Sintiger]

Also all true. However for context, the original reply was in response to the assertion all would play 100 games. I agree nobody knows.

It is pre season, everyone is flying

 

[mrposhman]

It is pre season, everyone is flying

Exactly, its pre-season - its guns, guns everywhere.

The season starts and Zips is licking his lips to throw out duds, duds, everywhere

 

[Sintiger]

Exactly, its pre-season - its guns, guns everywhere.

The season starts and Zips is licking his lips to throw out duds, duds, everywhere

When he had to rate our best kids he really wanted to list Holmes and Vandenhoogenband

 

[Smoking Aces]

Funny old PRE.

This thread is rating our kids and crystal balling into the future.

Next minute - How do you know player X will play 200 games when he has only played 1 game?? FMD!

 

[Tigers of Old]

Funny old PRE.

This thread is rating our kids and crystal balling into the future.

Next minute - How do you know player X will play 200 games when he has only played 1 game?? FMD!

Melodramatic again.

 

[Brodders17]

No one sees the perpetually injured Mate Colina as a long term career player? I wonder why?

He wasn't on Leysys list and we must follow Leysys rules!

 

[taztiger4]

Gibcus has hamstring issues.
Brown has played 1 game in two seasons.
Sonsie went backwards & got suspended.
Clarke lost his spot in the team. Didn’t win much footy.
Samson also lost his spot in the side to Soldo.

I hate to be pessimistic but until proven otherwise there’s question marks on all of our kids.

Righto Claw, what have you done with Toohey's ?

 

[Tigers of Old]

Righto Claw, what have you done with Toohey's ?

Forgive me if I'm not as bullish on our kids right now as a CC Tiger training report was back in the day.

 

[Smoking Aces]

Melodramatic again.

Come on TOO. Its Christmas!

 

[Tigers of Old]

Come on TOO. Its Christmas!

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

Gibcus has hamstring issues.
Brown has played 1 game in two seasons.
Sonsie went backwards & got suspended.
Clarke lost his spot in the team. Didn’t win much footy.
Samson also lost his spot in the side to Soldo.

I hate to be pessimistic but until proven otherwise there’s question marks on all of our kids.

Agree, no stand outs.
We have a 207cm bloke that can't take contested marks a midfielder that averages less then a full back and a winger that kicks like a donkey.
We are ok we have 3 flags.

 

[Sintiger]

Agree, no stand outs.
We have a 207cm bloke that can't take contested marks a midfielder that averages less then a full back and a winger that kicks like a donkey.
We are ok we have 3 flags.

Wrong Zips


Ryan is 206 cm