Robin Nahas

[TigerMasochist]

Small forward who kicks goals.

We haven't got one.

We let him go.

Great list management! :

Small forward who in his last season fumbled repeatedly, couldn't use his opposite side, couldn't stick a tackle, dragged the lip on the ground when made the sub.

No surprise we list managed him out, even Norf were forced to delist n rookie him back 'coz he wasn't performing. Good luck to Nacho Nahas if he finally makes a decent fist of his final chance, he's spent the last three years sailing pretty close to career oblivion.

 

[tigertim]

Small forward who in his last season fumbled repeatedly, couldn't use his opposite side, couldn't stick a tackle, dragged the lip on the ground when made the sub.

He was ordinary in 2013 in the 6 games he got. Anyhow I'd rather have a small forward who is averaging 1.6 goals a game and getting the ball 14 times a game rather than Morris.

 

[tigerdave]

Small forward who in his last season fumbled repeatedly, couldn't use his opposite side, couldn't stick a tackle, dragged the lip on the ground when made the sub.

No surprise we list managed him out, even Norf were forced to delist n rookie him back 'coz he wasn't performing. Good luck to Nacho Nahas if he finally makes a decent fist of his final chance, he's spent the last three years sailing pretty close to career oblivion.

Doing his job very well at the moment.Just like our small forwards.That's right-we haven't got any.

Once again - great list management!

 

[axlefoley]

Goes MIA against better opposition.

I can't believe the back peddling on here.

 

[tigerman]

He couldn't get a game with Norf last year, probably only getting a game because Wells hasn't played all year.

 

[Tenacious]

Goes MIA against better opposition.

I can't believe the back peddling on here.

Spot on.
He's ancient history so time to move on as well.

 

[Scoop]

It does hurt because we're investing draft picks and time into players like Lloyd and Butler, who have a ways to go just to reach Nahas standard. One of our most obvious deficiencies is specialist small forwards, but we gave one up who has since been a constant presence in a top 4 side, while the replacements can't make our team. That's the definition of poor list management because we are left in the lurch until someone else comes along. If we'd had an upgrade ready to go, then yes, the delisting of Nahas would be understandable.

And that's should be the very method of how the list is built.

 

[taztiger4]

It does hurt because we're investing draft picks and time into players like Lloyd and Butler, who have a ways to go just to reach Nahas standard. One of our most obvious deficiencies is specialist small forwards, but we gave one up who has since been a constant presence in a top 4 side, while the replacements can't make our team. That's the definition of poor list management because we are left in the lurch until someone else comes along. If we'd had an upgrade ready to go, then yes, the delisting of Nahas would be understandable.

sorry, but who are you talking about ?

 

[mainlandy]

sorry, but who are you talking about ?
[/quote
White

 

[AngryAnt]

Thought White was more of winger/outside mid than a small forward.

 

[Rancey18]

Last time I checked we were 8th on the ladder whereas North and Port were 11th and 12th despite playing an extra game than us...

 

[tigerlove]

Don't think you can claim Knights was ever picked as an upgrade replacement for Nahas, that's stretching it a bit.

I'm not saying he was a one for one replacement, what I am saying is Knights could well and truly cover Nahas's role and more.

 

[KnightersRevenge]

Last time I checked we were 8th on the ladder whereas North and Port were 11th and 12th despite playing an extra game than us...

Your facts are not welcome here.

 

[Chimptastic]

PRE; a place where you can be ripped apart and criticised for years and then praised and adored once you join another team.

 

[tigertim]

Last time I checked we were 8th on the ladder whereas North and Port were 11th and 12th despite playing an extra game than us...

Last time I checked Nahas had kicked 17 goals for the season. Our small forward has kicked 2.

 

[tigerdave]

Last time I checked Nahas had kicked 17 goals for the season. Our small forward has kicked 2.

:fing32

 

[tigertim]

PRE; a place where you can be ripped apart and criticised for years and then praised and adored once you join another team.

Who is praising him?

 

[CarnTheTiges]

I liked Robbie when he was at Punt Rd, although he was a master of not doing very much, but making himself look very involved, but did anyone who is advocating keeping him actually look at him in his last year at Richmond? He was clearly a player who didn't want to be at the club he was playing for. He's gone to North and good luck to him. If a player is somewhere they don't want to be for whatever reason they're not going to be much good.

 

[Bunnerz]

I liked Robbie when he was at Punt Rd, although he was a master of not doing very much, but making himself look very involved, but did anyone who is advocating keeping him actually look at him in his last year at Richmond? He was clearly a player who didn't want to be at the club he was playing for. He's gone to North and good luck to him. If a player is somewhere they don't want to be for whatever reason they're not going to be much good.

good call

 

[tigertim]

Robin was compared to Shed in another thread.

Since he left RFC he's played 31 games at North for 34 goals and ave 12.3 disposals and 3.6 marks (btw Hampson has ave 2.3 ....)

Shed has played 49 games for 41 goals and ave 20 disposals a game and ave 2.4 marks.