I might cop it here, but other than being a bit of *smile*, why would we not consider Braydon Sier. At his best the kid can play, good age, insider, good size, would have to be cheap
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
The Blair "Which?" Project
- Thread starter Tony Braxton-Hicks
- Start date
Keep coming around in circles re the Mitchell / JOM thing...
Was worrying about JOM staying on the park, but looking at his 2021 he played 18 games and went elite in poss/tackles/clearances.
Leaning more to the idea of JOM. Not super keen on Mitchell
Was worrying about JOM staying on the park, but looking at his 2021 he played 18 games and went elite in poss/tackles/clearances.
Leaning more to the idea of JOM. Not super keen on Mitchell
Apparently he posted on his Twitter account on Friday
"I'm not *"'*"' going anywhere"
The kid dosent want to go to western Sydney.
Not sure why the news of him going to GWS only broke last night..
I'm sceptical of a player that hasn't shown much and yet the Pies are trying to get him out. They need all the quality they can get, so if he can't make it with them, why would he make it with us? Maybe he's just not very good.
Because he is in the Jayden Stephenson class.
Lies to the club and dosent push himself hard enough.
He will be good for Bayswater or Lilydale next year
Don't disagree but I would have thought he was a much better player at Port than he has ever been at the Hawks, I reckon he has gone backwards with them.
True............. I think he's on the nose 'cause he's a *smile*, which we should be able to fix, unless he's a pea heart (see my Wingard comments). Other than clogging the list for a couple of years, what do we lose? He won't cost much, he could be a stop gap until the young bloke we draft building his tank and size.
agree Eddie.
Which is why GWS giving away pick 13 to the Hawks for him (if that's the deal in the end), is annoying.
That pick is so valuable - I must admit I was hoping we could somehow do a deal for that pick and the 7/2 swap together with our 2nds.
Mitchell is the best player of that lot by a mile. O'Meara is 2nd and the rest I wouldn't take even if they were free
Sure but he isn't on the list - Sicily is the one I'd be asking about. Injuries' mean he'll be cheap but if you can get him fit he is a significant upgrade on Houli.
Sicily is an intercept marker, not a running player. He's better than Houli at the former, not a patch at the latter. He's more like Vlastuin. We don't need him anywhere near as much as we need a mid.
He is actually all of the above. He is an elite kick, intercept marker and running player. He is also a lot tougher one on one than Bach. Hence a big upgrade
Sier is a dud, so you will cop it.
Why are clubs luring players on big deals only to want to offload them a year or two later. I am convinced some recruiting departments don't watch many games.
Suggest u watch some of his games. The only time he played as a key defender was on Lynch
Spent game time up forward, wing and half-back.
