Because if RCD was good enough, someone would have picked him upMaybe but not sure why that is relevant. He was specifically targeted by SOS and I find it a little amusing that he is ending up back with him.
Because if RCD was good enough, someone would have picked him upMaybe but not sure why that is relevant. He was specifically targeted by SOS and I find it a little amusing that he is ending up back with him.
Date yourself by using a saying from a tv show from your eraWhatyou talking about Willis
RCD is on a list, the De-list
I was talking about Liam Stocker and SOS ending up at the same club again as a coincidence given SOS was the one who did the pick swap to get him to Carlton and has defended him in the media since he was delisted.Because if RCD was good enough, someone would have picked him up
He started at GWS in 2011 from scratch, the side finished top 4 by 2016 and made a Grand Final in 2019.
And that's it?!?
He started at Carlton in 2014, finished in 2019 and that list looks ready to mature into a finals making side now as well and probably should have started last year, despite all the coaching upheaval in those years.
And how many 1st round draft picks has he burnt to build a side that missed playing Finals last year?!?
The guy is thick as a brick!
with half the teams in the competition being eligible for finals each year, coupled with better draft picks for the lower you finish, I'm not sure this is such a science as may be suggested.I know it's never acceptable to inject facts that contradict a good PRE kicking of an opponent, but I am baffled by the knocks on Silvagni as a list manager.
He started at GWS in 2011 from scratch, the side finished top 4 by 2016 and made a Grand Final in 2019.
He started at Carlton in 2014, finished in 2019 and that list looks ready to mature into a finals making side now as well and probably should have started last year, despite all the coaching upheaval in those years.
People can pick out all the micros of individual draft picks and priority picks but if the macro of a list manager is to create a list capable of playing finals and contending then he is miles ahead of most.
I know it's never acceptable to inject facts that contradict a good PRE kicking of an opponent, but I am baffled by the knocks on Silvagni as a list manager.
He started at GWS in 2011 from scratch, the side finished top 4 by 2016 and made a Grand Final in 2019.
He started at Carlton in 2014, finished in 2019 and that list looks ready to mature into a finals making side now as well and probably should have started last year, despite all the coaching upheaval in those years.
People can pick out all the micros of individual draft picks and priority picks but if the macro of a list manager is to create a list capable of playing finals and contending then he is miles ahead of most.
Here is his Carlton work.
Rating all of Stephen Silvagni's draft and trade acquisitions
We have given a tick or a cross against every player Stephen Silvagni brought to Carlton over his five years at the Blues.www.zerohanger.com
His 2015 is a smash out of the park.
The rest is pretty much meh. And his recruiting of plenty of GWS hacks to the blues has been disastrous.
If you judge him on 2015 he's been a success. But many many many more misses than hits.
And so he should have given the picks he had at both clubs over a long period of time.I know it's never acceptable to inject facts that contradict a good PRE kicking of an opponent, but I am baffled by the knocks on Silvagni as a list manager.
He started at GWS in 2011 from scratch, the side finished top 4 by 2016 and made a Grand Final in 2019.
He started at Carlton in 2014, finished in 2019 and that list looks ready to mature into a finals making side now as well and probably should have started last year, despite all the coaching upheaval in those years.
People can pick out all the micros of individual draft picks and priority picks but if the macro of a list manager is to create a list capable of playing finals and contending then he is miles ahead of most.