He's another I need to see more of. The youngest of the lot, December birthday. Big boy, good hands. Interested to see how he tests too.What about Jack Williams from WA, Spook and Scoop and others?
He's another I need to see more of. The youngest of the lot, December birthday. Big boy, good hands. Interested to see how he tests too.What about Jack Williams from WA, Spook and Scoop and others?
It makes sense. Look up any decent key fwd & you'll see the vast majority were taken in the 1st roundIt’s getting harder and harder for me to think of reasons why we shouldn’t draft Amiss with our first pick after Chol & CCJ have moved on. Huge swing by me I know but I think it may be necessary.
Ideally, we bundle our late picks and get the Dogs' first, which will be 19 or 20 after Daicos/Darcy bids. Effectively we'd then have 9, 17, 19, 28, 30.
I just can't see why Freo lets Amiss get past them at pick 8 (assuming they get it from Carlton) if he's genuine quality. In that case and if we have the two teens picks I think Andrew comes into consideration. Not saying he's the pick but you'd think about it.
Of course, Cerra might not go to Carlton. He could go to Melbourne. Carlton won't choose Amiss, they have McKay and Curnow.
The other possibility is Cerra chooses us and we trade 7 (9) to Freo. (We would do that in a heartbeat.)
So, at 9 it's Amiss, Cerra or whoever we think is best of what's left (Andrew, Sonsie, Sinn, Goater, Rachele the lead candidates).
At 17 and 19 we get two of Sonsie, Rachele, Wanganeen-Milera, Goater, Draper, Johnson, Sinn, Chesser, Butler, Wilmot. Pace and class.
At 28 and 30, two of Williams, JVR, Bazzo. Bookends. Or if we get Amiss or Andrew, one of those three and/or another running player(s), small forward(s) (Clarke, Motlop) or medium forward like Howes.
Bada-bing.
I take it you don’t rate him?I would back the chicken manure truck up if we used the Geelong pick on van Rooyen.
Not that early.I take it you don’t rate him?
Weideman is a spud. Clarke has pretty much said we won't be trading 7 so i'd say Cerra is out for us as that'd be Freo's asking price.Or trade 30 for Weideman.
Blair might change Clarke's mind if Cerra's available.Weideman is a spud. Clarke has pretty much said we won't be trading 7 so i'd say Cerra is out for us as that'd be Freo's asking price.
Melbourne will want much more than 30 for him. Minimum pick 16. And we tell them to get stuffed.Or trade 30 for Weideman.
I'm not sure either, Dan. He could go as early as Adelaide's pick or as late as our second pick and anywhere in between. He's a talent but there are concerns whether he's a true mid.Spook what's your take on Draper I reckon this kid is a beauty not sure we're he goes through.
If we could stop laughing.Melbourne will want much more than 30 for him. Minimum pick 16. And we tell them to get stuffed.
What's your knock on Weideman?Weideman is a spud. Clarke has pretty much said we won't be trading 7 so i'd say Cerra is out for us as that'd be Freo's asking price.
Ideally, we bundle our late picks and get the Dogs' first, which will be 19 or 20 after Daicos/Darcy bids. Effectively we'd then have 9, 17, 19, 28, 30.
I just can't see why Freo lets Amiss get past them at pick 8 (assuming they get it from Carlton) if he's genuine quality. In that case and if we have the two teens picks I think Andrew comes into consideration. Not saying he's the pick but you'd think about it.
Of course, Cerra might not go to Carlton. He could go to Melbourne. Carlton won't choose Amiss, they have McKay and Curnow.
The other possibility is Cerra chooses us and we trade 7 (9) to Freo. (We would do that in a heartbeat.)
So, at 9 it's Amiss, Cerra or whoever we think is best of what's left (Andrew, Sonsie, Sinn, Goater, Rachele the lead candidates).
At 17 and 19 we get two of Sonsie, Rachele, Wanganeen-Milera, Goater, Draper, Johnson, Sinn, Chesser, Butler, Wilmot. Pace and class.
At 28 and 30, two of Williams, JVR, Bazzo. Bookends. Or if we get Amiss or Andrew, one of those three and/or another running player(s), small forward(s) (Clarke, Motlop) or medium forward like Howes.
Bada-bing.
He's done nothing to deserve the hype he gets, played 1 good Final in '18 & that's it.What's your knock on Weideman?
He,s am interesting case, a bit like a Ben Griffiths type who is kept on potential.He's done nothing to deserve the hype he gets, played 1 good Final in '18 & that's it.
Does a heart cost another second rounder?Or trade 30 for Weideman.