2022 Mid Season Draft

[tigertim]

The HUN has us taking this guy:

10. Richmond – Hugo Hall-Kahan (Sandringham Dragons/NAB League)

Forward-wingman, 188cm, 78kg

Dan says: Richmond’s most pressing need is a key forward, but it would be best served waiting until the national draft for an exciting tall. Otherwise, it lacks medium forwards and wingmen, with Hall-Kahan having the potential to cover off either of these areas with his versatility and strong overhead marking. The Sandringham Dragons product has turned heads in the NAB League, averaging 14.8 disposals, 4.5 marks and two goals per game to stamp his authority as one of the best prospects available.

 

[Scoop]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

 

[nikolasmia]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

sounds really good

If he is quick, it sounds even better

 

[tigerdell]

No knock on Bauer or Hall-Kahan, but I don't see how they fit into our 22.
A mid sized forward would be great, but who gets shifted out?
We don't want to lose a runner. They can't be a 2nd ruck. The obvious is Castagna but I don't want to open that argument! Let's just say they probably don't yet have the running capacity to run across the ground.

So who goes out?
Where do they fit?

Instead a mid can be squeezed in

 

[Scoop]

sounds really good

If he is quick, it sounds even better

Not sure he's that quick. In this profile, speed is listed as an area of improvement. For his role that doesn't concern me, I'm sure his 3km trial time and running numbers at SANFL level are being assessed.

Josh Carmichael

Josh Carmichael is a mature-age talent who caught the eye through his SANFL footy after rising the ranks from local leagues.

central.rookieme.com

 

[TT33]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

Merbein Matty Knights territory.

 

[Billy24]

Geez Jacob BAUER looks like he is an elite marking forward - bucket hands. Funny kicking action that looks accurate. Will be a nice pick up for someone

His goal kicking approach for a set shot is unusual. His first couple of steps he looks like he is going to kick on his left, then he does a sort of skip step and gets back on his right boot. His accuracy looks good, from a small sample size.
He doesn’t have the strange skip step with his in play field kicking, a good thing as he could get caught a lot if he did.

 

[Dont Argue]

For those in the know, what is the next level down from AFL around the country? If it’s VFL then we should take comfort that we have a couple of boys who have equipped themselves well in our VFL team and would understand their abilities. That goes a long way to managing the risk.
My fear with the other leagues around the country is that they are inferior in speed and pressure which dictates a players ability to make the right decisions and to execute accordingly.
But again I’m not totally across SANFL or the WAFL and would appreciate any feedback

 

[TigerForce]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

Looks a bit stocky, how fast is he?

 

[thegdog]

His goal kicking approach for a set shot is unusual. His first couple of steps he looks like he is going to kick on his left, then he does a sort of skip step and gets back on his right boot. His accuracy looks good, from a small sample size.
He doesn’t have the strange skip step with his in play field kicking, a good thing as he could get caught a lot if he did.

Agree

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

What time is it on??

 

[T-Shirt Tommy]

What time is it on??

6pm

 

[T-Shirt Tommy]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

Not sure he lasts to our pick.

 

[nswtiger]

James Blanck from the Hawks VFL .for me ...........ready made ...........​

 

[Tortured Tiger]

Not sure he lasts to our pick.

You are right, very unlikely, expected to go top five from what I have read.

 

[Tortured Tiger]

The mid season draft should always be used on a type who can provide instant impact.

That would be brilliant but in reality how often does that happen, especially at pick 10 ?

 

[Scoop]

Not sure he lasts to our pick.

I'd take Culley if I could but he will be well gone. I really think we need mids.

 

[King Kong]

I would take Josh Carmichael. 188cm , 89 kg onballer out of the SANFL. At 22 years old, this is his first exposure to any big league football, has come from Merbin up in the Sunraysia league to West Adeliade. So he's made the leap and for me, there is scope for further improvement. A lot of Jai Newcomb about this story. We need mids. He first the age bracket gap of out list. Right size to play quickly, shown he can win his own footy and fills a need on out list.

West Adelaide - SANFL

sanfl.com.au

Will be gone in the top 5 picks unfortunately

 

[King Kong]

James Blanck from the Hawks VFL .for me ...........ready made ...........​

Gone to Hawks

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

6pm

I'm really nervous