His comments around the Williams suspension were bizarre. His 1st position was because Webster didn't want to deck him meant that he shouldn't be suspended.
Just on the Williams suspension, the manner of decision making around whether a hit is of low, medium or high impact seems to really miss the point about concussion injuries.
The present mode of classifying relies on whether the victim is knocked unconscious or whether instead he is able to get up and play on.
A concussion injury which is sustained as a result of a knock to the head is likely to be cumulative and so whether a player is able to get up and play on is more likely to be a reflection of his past history of concussions than anything else.
This particular bump was delivered directly to the head by Williams after running at speed for 5-10 meters and finally taking to the air immediately before impact.
To describe it as of medium rather than high impact is misguided and helps perpetuate the ongoing risk of post retirement tragedies like Shane Tuck.