That was the process I was taught and upheld whilst I was an umpire many moons ago!
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
ARC Appeal
- Thread starter snags
- Start date
I thought that was the case, thanks for confirming.
it is never spoken about when they talk about goal umpire decisions.
surely they have the down the ground vision to check what the field umpire thought?
Feel like Basil Fawlty mentioning the war but looks like the AFL can say sorry when no ARC involved.
This thread needs to be binned into the internet ether for all of our collective mental health. I had finally put the ARC issue behind me but now want to hurt someone again
So the AFL can admit an umpire made an error in one game, but the ARC is infallible and would never be wrong.
"Our TV stations have over the last couple of decades developed technology that is far superior and more accurate than a mere human brain equipped with a 3-dimensional optical system. That old stuff has been around for the last few hundred million years and our stuff is much better and proven."
"Our TV stations have over the last couple of decades developed technology that is far superior and more accurate than a mere human brain equipped with a 3-dimensional optical system. That old stuff has been around for the last few hundred million years and our stuff is much better and proven."
Now that the wound has been re-opened, I watched the footage again and still can't see any definitive evidence to overturn the goal umpire and, frankly, still think the footage points to it being a goal regardless
Umpire's call is a goal..umpire's call is a goal..umpire's call is a goal..
Unless the AFL don’t want it to be.Umpire's call is a goal..umpire's call is a goal..umpire's call is a goal..
If the central umpire is not to sure he will put his hands behind his back and says to the goal umpire all clear, indicating that the goal umpire has the call.
The goal umpire was half a metre away from the goal post and as so had the best position of any one to make the judgment call this includes the numpties up in ARC.
They stuffed up but we just have to move on otherwise we just become salty.
The goal umpire was half a metre away from the goal post and as so had the best position of any one to make the judgment call this includes the numpties up in ARC.
They stuffed up but we just have to move on otherwise we just become salty.
Yeah well the afl can still gagf. Still a mob of cheating pricks.
Today was a beautiful, sunny day, went to visit my sister in Ivanhoe, then drove back and passed this sign......
Geez Ivanhoe’s gone downhill.Today was a beautiful, sunny day, went to visit my sister in Ivanhoe, then drove back and passed this sign......
View attachment 17267
Used to joke with Bubbles a few times on the fine line between Ivanhoe and Heidelberg (where he lived
)That dud has moved. Bayside Bubbles now.Used to joke with Bubbles a few times on the fine line between Ivanhoe and Heidelberg (where he lived
