Changes verses the Swannies - Easter Round

[artball]

little bemused by the team selection..
not sure what the Coaches are aiming at this year but you'd think in the transitional state we're in
that you'd reward effort and punish non-effort?
even if it's just to have a look at some other names on the bigger stage

 

[ToraToraTora]

What is their obsession with Dow?

 

[CarnTheTiges]

What is their obsession with Dow?

He inherited George’s photos?

 

[ToraToraTora]

Jesus we are gonna get flogged.

 

[TigerForce]

He inherited George’s photos?

But George had Dimma photos, maybe Dow's got Ooze photos...

 

[ToraToraTora]

the bench is weird.

 

[toothless]

What is their obsession with Dow?

Yze's pet, each coach has at least one.

 

[tiger76]

What is their obsession with Dow?

A top 3 pick

 

[mad_tiggy911]

Is Livingstone calling these shots? Some *smile* never changes!

 

[Carter]

For those looking for some kind of intent with the changes, look no further than Melbourne’s game plan - hugely contested stoppages as a means of defending.

Not surprising that he’d wanna keep as many midfielders in as he can, including a ruck rotation to boot.

The way we play is already a lot different to the Dimma method of strangling the ball back and off to the races.

Yze just wants to win the ball. Dow is one of the few true midfielders we have off Dimma’s list and he will be persisted with as long as humanly possible.

McAuliffe is a monty for an Yze-coached side. Makes sense to let the lad debut with friends and family watching in SA.

 

[daniel30]

To many senior players not playing well are being gifted games that's a concern. Match committee are either clueless or got blinkers on stuck in the past.

 

[daniel30]

Is Livingstone calling these shots? Some *smile* never changes!

I get this feeling to his a issue at the club can't let go.

 

[Spirit of Jack]

It makes sense to debut McAuliffe in SA. My other thought, he was incredible in the VFL last week, but hardly sighted in the last quarter - not sure if he was being rested on the bench or simply faded due to lack of endurance.

 

[Quickdraw]

It makes sense to debut McAuliffe in SA. My other thought, he was incredible in the VFL last week, but hardly sighted in the last quarter - not sure if he was being rested on the bench or simply faded due to lack of endurance.

Might have had a touch of leather poisoning from his first 3 quarters

 

[TigerFurious]

Match committee giving Dow more chances than he deserves. They clearly want him to succeed. I think that when the axe does eventually fall, that will be it for Thomson. He will never play at the top level again.

 

[Sintiger]

We have had a lot of posts over the pre season about giving young players an extended run at it but then we have complaints about players being given an extended run …

This is not necessarily the team I would pick but I understand why some like Moju, Dow, Banks etc are being given a few games rather than just in and then out again.

Mcauliffe’s time will come soon enough. I’d also like to see Cumberland get another shot at some point as well as a couple of others like Clarke and Bauer.

 

[Smoking Aces]

Yze won’t make wholesale changes. He said in his presser last week that the team has been unsettled due to the injuries we have had.

I am expecting only the two changes.

MRJ and Sonsie to come in at the expense of Banks and Lefau.

Miller to hold his spot over Young.

Lefau to be the sub.

Miller - McLean
Grimes - MacDonald
Vlastuin - Amartey
Broad to to take Heeney when resting forward.

 

[btoz_01]

We have had a lot of posts over the pre season about giving young players an extended run at it but then we have complaints about players being given an extended run …

This is not necessarily the team I would pick but I understand why some like Moju, Dow, Banks etc are being given a few games rather than just in and then out again.

Mcauliffe’s time will come soon enough. I’d also like to see Cumberland get another shot at some point as well as a couple of others like Clarke and Bauer.

But it’s the same ones that get gifted games and failed
I don’t see Clarke Cumbo Coulthard Hugo given a run of games

 

[Brodders17]

But it’s the same ones that get gifted games and failed
I don’t see Clarke Cumbo Coulthard Hugo given a run of games

We have played 3 games. There is plenty of time.

 

[RoarEmotion]

But it’s the same ones that get gifted games and failed
I don’t see Clarke Cumbo Coulthard Hugo given a run of games

With Hardwick….