Perplexing he wasn’t played as the third forward given the injury run. Have coaches forgotten 2017 & 2018? Apparently so. No longer a winger under these rules but a more than handy half forward & pinch hit midfielder.
-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Josh Caddy
- Thread starter Rancey18
- Start date
Couldn't agree more would have added toughness and strength in attack and onball. We looked small and feeble alot this season. MC got this wrong IMO!
I'd be annoyed if I were Caddy. We knew what we were getting when we traded for him. He changed his body shape to fit a new role for us, more than once.
Ultimate club man in my eyes. Was a bit undisciplined at times, but you can't have a hard edge and not commit too many frees. Unfairly maligned by many on here.
Ultimate club man in my eyes. Was a bit undisciplined at times, but you can't have a hard edge and not commit too many frees. Unfairly maligned by many on here.
Poorly treated. Not the way I expect my football club to treat players.
Jack & Caddy have always been fighting for the same spot up forward once Lynch arrived.
I doubt you’ve got any idea how he’s been treated by the club.
As a member for close to 40 years, when I see a two time premiership player consistently ignored for rookies (including Samson Ryan on a wet night against St Kilda when we played three rucks), I absolutely have a right to make a comment. So F off
I reckon the move to the wing was just wrong. However, it was hard to find another spot for him in the team. Seems to just not fit in our team any more. Surely could do some good elsewhere.
Since we are not playing him I would let him walk if he wants to.
DS
Since we are not playing him I would let him walk if he wants to.
DS
I have a feeling the double 50 metres he gave away against Port last year was probably the last straw.
Dimma was furious in the box and he was dropped the following week from memory.
I've always been a fan and in my eyes a RFC champ.
Dimma was furious in the box and he was dropped the following week from memory.
I've always been a fan and in my eyes a RFC champ.
I think Caddy knows where he stands. Contrary to some I think he acquitted himself quite well on the wing. No better or worse than KMac and Pickett. 3 into 2 doesn't go and now with more focus on youngsters I feel his time is limited. Doubt there'd be much in a trade but worth finding out.
Smart footballer. Try him down back before we (try to) sell him for peanuts.
(Love ya, Josh.)
(Love ya, Josh.)
Love Cadds as well, but I still like him on a HFF. Knock is speed when defence is needed.
Lynch and Jack are too slow there too so three with perhaps Captain Crunch in there will be way too slow. We’ve seen enough of the oppo walking it out of our forward line all this year.
want to fit him in the forward line but can’t see it working or happening unfortunately. I reckon he’d kick 20-25 for the year still but have to weigh it up against the pain the other way.
Last edited:
id prefer to leave him in a Forward pocket or flank
Except he’s never played the type of forward those guys played. Love Caddy but as others have said his time in our forward line ended when Lynch was recruited.
