Josh Toy

[Baloo]

No, if we are after Toy we still need to hold onto our first pick.

If Toy was in this draft and was available at pick 6, you wouldn't get him ?

 

[BBC]

If Toy wanted to return home from the GC then I would offer pick 3 and McGuane in a flash.

 

[Opulentus Tigris]

If Toy wanted to return home from the GC then I would offer pick 3 and McGuane in a flash.

Pick 6. I'm not sure pick 6 is all that important to GC, they more than anything need mature bodies. Otherwise they will get smashed in contested ball next year. This why I believe, any team dealing with GC wouldn't necessarily need to offer up a first round pick. They already have an abundance of those.

 

[pahoffm]

I feel that a mature regular player that could fit somewhere in their spine or midfield, who could give GC another 5 years, would easily compensate them as a trade for Toy.

 

[GEDS1]

Phanto if that meant any of McGuane, Thirsty or Rance can you please arrange for it to happen.

Phanto do you see Toy as an improved Chad Cornes ?

 

[thomas the tiger]

Does tha mean you do not rate Toy. Giving a solid player for the potential 10 year player?

 

[Barnzy]

What's with all the massive speculation of Toy trades? Has it been officially announced that he doesn't want to go to the GC and I missed it?

All I've heard is a couple of internet rumours.

 

[mtench]

I feel that a mature regular player that could fit somewhere in their spine or midfield, who could give GC another 5 years, would easily compensate them as a trade for Toy.

Id give up Tambling and McGuane for Toy!

 

[WesternTiger]

What's with all the massive speculation of Toy trades? Has it been officially announced that he doesn't want to go to the GC and I missed it?

All I've heard is a couple of internet rumours.

Like most of the other trade / draft speculation this time of year.

 

[jimbob]

From a big bodied player for GC - could Shane Tuck come into this equation to wangle Toy to us? After all - longevity shouldn't be a problem with the Tuck genes.

 

[GoodOne]

Pick 6. I'm not sure pick 6 is all that important to GC, they more than anything need mature bodies. Otherwise they will get smashed in contested ball next year. This why I believe, any team dealing with GC wouldn't necessarily need to offer up a first round pick. They already have an abundance of those.

Spot on. They wont want draft picks.

 

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

As a local boy who with a mature body who can hold down a key position, McGuane would be worth something to them.

 

[mtench]

As a local boy who with a mature body who can hold down a key position, McGuane would be worth something to them.

We can only hope!

 

[thomas the tiger]

No mention of Toy being part of any trade deals

 

[Chiang Mai Tiger]

Kissing that one goodbye

 

[johnson2richo2003]

Kissing that one goodbye

Not quite ;D
Apparently the Boy isn,t enoying life up North and wants to head back to Vic.
Expect GC to put him on the Trade Table.

 

[Colonel]

Interesting, wonder if we are sniffing around? The boy has a lot of talent

 

[Streak]

I'd definately give up our first pick in this year's draft for him.

But think it will take more than that.

 

[Barnzy]

I've watched him a number of times this year and he hasn't impressed me one bit. Doesn't look quick, doesn't rack up the ball and has been exposed defensively giving up a fair few goals. What made him so impressive as a junior? Just wondering because he was hyped up so much and I haven't seen it so far.

 

[vinpaul]

I've watched him a number of times this year and he hasn't impressed me one bit. Doesn't look quick, doesn't rack up the ball and has been exposed defensively giving up a fair few goals. What made him so impressive as a junior? Just wondering because he was hyped up so much and I haven't seen it so far.

Yeah Id agree with that, Ive watched him closely and he has not been all that impressive considering he was touted as a top 3 pick.