Agree. The criticism of these kids is borderline pathetic. Look at the seniors who turned their toes up.
Yep. Some very highly credentialed and highly paid players did SFA tonight. The kids at least had a crack.
Agree. The criticism of these kids is borderline pathetic. Look at the seniors who turned their toes up.
100% it is.Agree. The criticism of these kids is borderline pathetic. Look at the seniors who turned their toes up.
Its unfortunate that this will always happen.Don't let facts stand in the way of a good story.
I can't believe some of the criticism of our young guys. They got no opportunity last year, and most of them have played a couple of senior games.
Seriously, give them a chance.
But so did the youth for every team in Victoria. Yet others are performing and our guys are struggling.Agree. And the young players missed an entire season last year for their development.
Put those 4 back in and those kids will be back in the twos.Our kids are good. They just need time and support.
Take the equivalent of prestia, Cotch, Lambert, Edwards out of any team and they will struggle
That’s a great point. The cut backs have hurt. We lost 2 very good assistant coaches and performance / physio. Can’t remember the guys name but he has gone to Sydney. Massive loss.But so did the youth for every team in Victoria. Yet others are performing and our guys are struggling.
Footy Dept cutbacks hurting us I think. When you're taking talent from deeper in the draft, I think you need to spend a bit extra getting the most out of them. We may not be in a position to do that anymore.
Rob Inness was our rehab and strengthening guy, brilliant at his job, has gone up to Sydney to be the Peter Burge of the Swans, (which is a promotion), so no small loss.That’s a great point. The cut backs have hurt. We lost 2 very good assistant coaches and performance / physio. Can’t remember the guys name but he has gone to Sydney. Massive loss.
That’s his name. He was constantly mentioned by players as being a big influence on their recovery.Rob Inness was our rehab and strengthening guy, brilliant at his job, has gone up to Sydney to be the Peter Burge of the Swans, (which is a promotion), so no small loss.
4 of those have played 9 games between them. 2020 was a write-off for player development. Hard to make judgement until they've been given a go at the top level. That'll happen moving forward.Players like ross rcd martyn dow naish stack are not coming along quick enough.
Compare the pair. Same age, same draft, same sorta position. Schoenberg spends more time forward.Richmond fans are buying the narrative because Tom Green is a descendant of a great. But the narrative, as usual with GWS players, is hyperbole. If not fraud.
Green is pretty good size and a pretty good athlete. Compare him to Harry Schoenberg, a midget who can't raise a canter.
Harry knows where to go and gets there. He knows where to send less intelligent team mates. And he does it in a n instant. And Schoenberg looks nimble and sometimes brisk on a football ground.
Tom Green has demonstrated no such characteristics. I tender the second quarter of the GWS v Coll game on the weekend. It was still dry and Green's instructions, if they could be divined from his play, were to get involved. He was well below the level.
Now, I didn't cherry pick this quarter. I chose it because I saw my usual Tom Green.
Green went 10 in his draft because Carlton chose him there. If Matt Clark had taken him there we'd have have had a dozen or more bust calls already.
I'm not writing Green off altogether because he looks to be low on confidence atm. But I vote against statics and Green is one. And on current form, even career form, Green is mediocre imo.