Umpire farce - Getting worse by the minute!

[tigersnake]

HTB/ incorrect disposal still a raffle. What I'm finding strange ATM is the commentators views are a raffle as well. A perfect example of this was a free against Guelfi in the Hawthorn fwd line last night. He grabbed the ball in a pack, then just held on to it standing up in a big pack of players kind of waving the ball around a bit, not even a fake attempt at handball. Got spun around and jostled by the pack for ages, ump hgave him ages to make an attempt, his arms weren't even pinned, but he was carrying on as if he was miming that they were. Then finally blew the whistle for holding the ball. It was HTB all day long, fair dinkum. The Ess players carried on, and the commentators, led by Richo, all said 'geez thats a bit rough' etc. WTH?

 

[tigertim]

Tigers now on bottom of the free kick differential ladder at -34. Second last is Carlton at -33 and then Port Adelaide at -29.

On top is Collingwood with +50 then Western Bulldogs with +48 then Crows with +42.

But rest assured, for the 3rd year running there’s no bias against Richmond....

 

[KnightersRevenge]

What form do you see that bias occur in TT?

I'm coming around go the Reverse strip theory. We do better with the umps in the Reverse strip. The predominantly black jumper hides some infringements from view. The umps eyes are drawn to the lighter colours and so "see more" frees going that way?

 

[LeeToRainesToRoach]

HTB/ incorrect disposal still a raffle. What I'm finding strange ATM is the commentators views are a raffle as well. A perfect example of this was a free against Guelfi in the Hawthorn fwd line last night. He grabbed the ball in a pack, then just held on to it standing up in a big pack of players kind of waving the ball around a bit, not even a fake attempt at handball. Got spun around and jostled by the pack for ages, ump hgave him ages to make an attempt, his arms weren't even pinned, but he was carrying on as if he was miming that they were. Then finally blew the whistle for holding the ball. It was HTB all day long, fair dinkum. The Ess players carried on, and the commentators, led by Richo, all said 'geez thats a bit rough' etc. WTH?

Was that when his right arm was pinned and he held the ball in his left? The umpire gave him an eternity to get rid of it, at least twice as long as he should've got.

Eventually he managed to get it onto his boot for a 2m kick. Maybe the commentators thought he got the ball moving in the end, so play on (which seems to be the general interpretation).

 

[Tigermad2005]

Back where we belong.

 

[Fighting Fury]

Visual aid.
I used numbers from prior to the start of the round (so we will be top of the ladder by Sunday night)

 

[Brodders17]

Was that when his right arm was pinned and he held the ball in his left? The umpire gave him an eternity to get rid of it, at least twice as long as he should've got.

Eventually he managed to get it onto his boot for a 2m kick. Maybe the commentators thought he got the ball moving in the end, so play on (which seems to be the general interpretation).

i dont mind that interpretation, as always though the problem in inconsistency.

 

[123cups]

I'm coming around go the Reverse strip theory. We do better with the umps in the Reverse strip. The predominantly black jumper hides some infringements from view. The umps eyes are drawn to the lighter colours and so "see more" frees going that way?

Generally speaking this is a proven form of umpire bias in other sports.

 

[HR]

Generally speaking this is a proven form of umpire bias in other sports.

Been spruiking this for years, not only the overall colour but the contrasting colours.
Its real. No doubt.

 

[HR]

Wrestling move from Hunt, umpire 2 meters away, holds the figure 4 leglock for an eternity, umpire does SFA as usual, now I will expect infringed upon docker to get 2 weeks! This is the umpires fault. Should have been a 50m when the leg lock was applied. The umpires inaction actually is the problem!

 

[frickenel]

Well after the first quarter free kick and goal to Mason Cox v the Dogs, it's confirmed.............

The umpires love big Cox

 

[tigersnake]

why do the umps love essendon? kept em in it. Just itching to pay frees to them. Giants can't buy one.

 

[Tenacious Tiges]

why do the umps love essendon? kept em in it. Just itching to pay frees to them. Giants can't buy one.

Them and Colonwood loved by the Dumpires

 

[MB78]

The AFL has again failed tonight. Clear touched ball and the players let the umpire know. How hard is it to check the replay before the game restarts?

Farce. S Hockey has put his nose in front of Gil as being the worst football administrator in the game.

 

[Bill James]

GWS baldface flogged.

 

[craig]

GWS baldface flogged.

Dons got a nice run from them tonight.

 

[Ian4]

The AFL has again failed tonight. Clear touched ball and the players let the umpire know. How hard is it to check the replay before the game restarts?

Farce. S Hockey has put his nose in front of Gil as being the worst football administrator in the game.

Just my view, but I think the video review should be for goal line and goal post decisions only. not touched during play. You can never be 100% conclusive of those.

 

[tigertim]

Free kick differential top and bottom 3:

1: WB +51
2: Collingwood + 50
3: ADELAIDE +43

16: Port -25
17: Richmond-32
18: Carlton-34

 

[craig]

Free kick differential top and bottom 3:

1: WB +51
2: Collingwood + 50
3: ADELAIDE +43

16: Port -25
17: Richmond-32
18: Carlton-34

At least we are consistent , with past seasons.

But the charge is on we are off the bottom

 

[tigertim]

Top and bottom 3 of the free kick differential ladder:

1...need I say who with +65
2: Adelaide +47
3: Western Bulldogs +42

16: Carlton-27
17: GWS-33
18: need I say who -35