Changes V Eagles

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

Someone had to come in for Prestia, as long as Aarts is played in the guts I'm ok with his selection.
He has played midfield for short periods of a game before, would like to get a look at him playing a whole game there.

I wouldn't.

 

[tigerman]

I wouldn't.

Unfortunately RCD and Dow aren't exactly kicking the door down.

 

[artball]

Unfortunately RCD and Dow aren't exactly kicking the door down.

sad but true

 

[btoz_01]

Someone had to come in for Prestia, as long as Aarts is played in the guts I'm ok with his selection.
He has played midfield for short periods of a game before, would like to get a look at him playing a whole game there.

If FAarts comes in we’re tanking

 

[Tigerfan]

I’d suggest

Prestia out
Stack in
Lambert sub

 

[tigertim]

George in. Good lord….

 

[btoz_01]

George in as HF

Interchange 45] Hugo Ralphsmith, [20] Ivan Soldo, [49] Maurice Rioli, [7] Liam Baker
emergencies 16] Jake Aarts, [44] Sydney Stack, [31] Rhyan Mansell, [23] Kane Lambert

 

[snags]

That's the worse news I've had this week and I've had a week from hell. Short sighted this decision.

 

[btoz_01]

George in. Good lord….

Didn’t have to do much in vfl to get his spot back

 

[jb03]

Geez we can be boring and predictable at selection.

 

[year of the tiger]

Dam - was really hoping for Stack tbh.

 

[TigerForce]

Geez we can be boring and predictable at selection.

Are we trying to get him back to form? Ridiculous decision IMO. Could've been a good chance for Stacky to gain more form. Do we blame this decision on coach bias??

 

[Redford]

Great move. I can enjoy Ridley’s spleen rupturing again now.

 

[WesternTiger]

Are we trying to get him back to form? Ridiculous decision IMO. Could've been a good chance for Stacky to gain more form. Do we blame this decision on coach bias??

George had a shitful first half of the year. Went back to VFL. Played three games - were the output of his three games great than Stacks? Did he do all he was instructed to do by the coaches?

I'd love to see Stacky back in the firsts however George is a three time premiership player who in the pasts has played his part. Hopefully he can do it again for a 4th medal.

 

[Tigerfan]

I’d suggest

Prestia out
Castagna in
Lambert or stack (sub)

 

[TigerForce]

George had a shitful first half of the year. Went back to VFL. Played three games - were the output of his three games great than Stacks? Did he do all he was instructed to do by the coaches?

I'd love to see Stacky back in the firsts however George is a three time premiership player who in the pasts has played his part. Hopefully he can do it again for a 4th medal.

Well let's see him move and do something worthwhile instead of playing like a ghost. Hopefully Stacky's the sub as Lambo's better off resting and not needed for Weagles.

 

[St Kevin]

 

[tigertim]

The Eagles side isn’t the worst I’ve seen on paper:

Williams Darling Rioli
Trew Waterman Ryan
Gaff Kelly Cripps
Jones Yeo Duggan
Hurn Barrass Bazzo
Natanui
Redden
Shuey

inter: Rotham Petrucelle West Hough

 

[craig]

NO Stack and George back in = Meh

 

[snags]

George had a shitful first half of the year. Went back to VFL. Played three games - were the output of his three games great than Stacks? Did he do all he was instructed to do by the coaches?

I'd love to see Stacky back in the firsts however George is a three time premiership player who in the pasts has played his part. Hopefully he can do it again for a 4th medal.

George has played a "role". Many of us have scratched our heads and arses wondering what that was but I digress. Where as we know what stack could bring has a much higher ceiling. There's no doubt george will contribute but I truly believe there's an opportunity lost here.