Sydney Stack

[silvertiger]

Papers stamped IMO.

Farce that he wasn't chosen.

Agree. It's a joke. he was fantastic last week.He has more skill and smarts than George (like 500% more). So Stack matches George for his only attribute - pressure.....and they still don't pick him. There must be something else going on.

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

If it helps in any way i think you're full of

Yep

 

[King Kong]

Dimmas favourites BS raises its ugly head once again. Noah and Stack should both be in ahead of Cantstandya

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

Dimmas favourites BS raises its ugly head once again. Noah and Stack should both be in ahead of Cantstandya

Kong we all know, he never makes big Changes win or lose.
If Prestia wasn't injured, he wouldve gone unchanged.
Regardless of last week's result.
Balta Cotchin and Lambert are the only ones that will come in

 

[Dont Argue]

Jason Castagna (13 disposals, nine tackles, four inside-50s, three goals)

"I thought he was fantastic. He importantly took his opportunities in front of goal, but when we needed hard, tough footy in the last quarter he stepped in with a team-high nine tackles, and played his role really well."

And your point is?

 

[zgod]

We will unleash him 3 weeks from finals and he will find form and come September he will go down in tigers folklore.
Mark my words .

 

[Smoking Aces]

And your point is?

You said who said he has been playing well in the reserves. I just pointed out the coach has. So that’s my point.

 

[seven]

Yep

Your source was correct.

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

Your source was correct.

They shouldve picked him

 

[seven]

They shouldve picked him

Maybe Castanga will prove us wrong....

 

[bairdy380]

Even I’m head scratching this week

 

[caesar]

Everyone has been calling for Syd to play in defence, you've got your wish, named in back pocket in the VFL

 

[Little Ziggyadee]

We have lost this game at the selection table

Even I’m head scratching this week

 

[Dont Argue]

You said who said he has been playing well in the reserves. I just pointed out the coach has. So that’s my point.

Read his match report.
Everyone played well.
Trust your own eyes.
13 disposals? Not good enough for me

 

[Smoking Aces]

Read his match report.
Everyone played well.
Trust your own eyes.
13 disposals? Not good enough for me

I did watch my the game and you can’t say he didn’t play well. I don’t get caught up in disposals.

 

[AngryAnt]

Didn't Stack only have 16 possies?

 

[Tony Braxton-Hicks]

Even I’m head scratching this week

Someone send some of this to Dimma. It describes George's impact.

.

 

[Tigers of Old]

On the face of it he should have been selected this week. Future not looking so bright.

 

[Streak]

I'm not going to read too much in to it. Maybe his papers are stamped, maybe they aren't. Stacky hasn't earned a recall for some reason, I have no idea what it is.

The coach has to have a big say on who is selected for obvious reasons, and Dimma thinks not yet.

And if Dimma is playing his favourites, then fine with me. I'll take a 3 time Tiger premiership coach's decision every day of the week, and Dimma really hasn't put a foot wrong over the last 5 years.

While I personally don't see it, I'll even back him on keeping faith with George.

 

[tigerlove]

I did watch my the game and you can’t say he didn’t play well. I don’t get caught up in disposals.

There is no way Castagna was anywhere near as influential as Stack (or Cumberland) in the last 2 weeks regardless of stats. Before last game Castagna was just average, consistently missing targets. I do sort of understand not selecting Stack as he's only started firing last 2 games and they want to see him string a few games together but Cumberland has been extremely consistent. The only reason Castagna could possibly be selected against the bottom team is try and get him into form. He's been average for a long time though and imo needed to show a lot more at VFL level week in week out.

This was the perfect time to try something different but no.