-
IMPORTANT // Please look after your loved ones, yourself and be kind to others. If you are feeling that the world is too hard to handle there is always help - I implore you not to hesitate in contacting one of these wonderful organisations Lifeline and Beyond Blue ... and I'm sure reaching out to our PRE community we will find a way to help. T.
Most underrated player to wear yellow and black
- Thread starter Sintiger
- Start date
I love Jake's game against Collingwood.
Im biased, but I loved Jakes game later in his career up forward.
Between him and Tommy Hislop slapped there entire team.
Dave was certainly underrated by Salty. Who will forget how he bragged how he loved the Astbury/Hawkins match up at halftime in the 2020 grannie.
Hawkins 2nd half = 1 point
Dave was the ultimate unsung hero, solid with a capital S
Taylor Hunt, Stevan Jackson, Todd BremanYep. Up there with Chris Blurton, Trent Knobel and Addam Maric for impact as a player from another club
Underrated by who?
If we're talking AFL, media etc, then Vlaustin. Should be a multiple AA.
If we're talking by our own then Jackson, Pettifer, Castagna.
If we're talking AFL, media etc, then Vlaustin. Should be a multiple AA.
If we're talking by our own then Jackson, Pettifer, Castagna.
In the 80s Id have to say Greg Strachan, Barry Rowlings and Graeme Landy although my memory is limited early 80s. Michael Pickering.
Michael Mitchell 80s into 90s.
In the 90s - Matty Rogers, Nick Daffy , Jason Torney and Andrew Kellaway, Jamie Tape, Mark Merenda
In the 00s - Ivan Maric - helped changed the culture at the club, Will Thursfield.
Of the last 10 years - Kane Lambert, Josh Caddy, Dion Prestia , Shane Edwards, Dave Astbury, Nick Vlastuin, Nathan Broad.
Torney matured into a bloody good player. Luckily he only got to 100 games at the RFC for any father sons.
Michael Mitchell 80s into 90s.
In the 90s - Matty Rogers, Nick Daffy , Jason Torney and Andrew Kellaway, Jamie Tape, Mark Merenda
In the 00s - Ivan Maric - helped changed the culture at the club, Will Thursfield.
Of the last 10 years - Kane Lambert, Josh Caddy, Dion Prestia , Shane Edwards, Dave Astbury, Nick Vlastuin, Nathan Broad.
Torney matured into a bloody good player. Luckily he only got to 100 games at the RFC for any father sons.
Last edited:
Castagna was pretty underrated by the general public and our own supporters. Triple premiership player and no one from PRE could even fit him in their best 22 combined premiership side!
No contest.
Mathew Richardson.
Would have been an all time great in a good team.
Misunderstood by the footballing community.
Carried us on his back for a decade.
Opposition and commentators laughed a him.
The joke was on them
Mathew Richardson.
Would have been an all time great in a good team.
Misunderstood by the footballing community.
Carried us on his back for a decade.
Opposition and commentators laughed a him.
The joke was on them
Daffy was seriously under rated and then when Mick Malthouse called him the best small forward in the game everyone loved him too much.
